[konebyvax]

Really great audition and, sadly, downhill from there.

[Bad Juju]

God no, that's Frankie's crown.

[PigsCanFly27]

Come on, worst act in HISTORY? Personally I think she has a really nice sounding voice she's just had bad nights recently.

[Bob Evans]

Originally Posted by The Terminator

Frankie? Johnny? Wagner? I could go on but by the time I press the reply button there will probably be half a dozen people throwing even better examples out to show how ridiculous your question is.

At least Wagner was sort of entertaining

[notsupafizzal]

nope she has a great distinctive tone, she is quirky with it. she sings with emotion and has fragility with it. so no she isn't the worst

[BinCat]

Worst act in XFactor history?

One word. Ray

[hotmat3k]

Janet has been the most misguided! Shame on Kelly for spending most of her efforts on Misha. Seriously, Janet has been given some awful songs. No doubt Janet has some talent. Maybe they should of denied her entry to the live shows to let her grow up a little and encourage her to enter next year.

[Bad Juju]

Originally Posted by BinCat

Worst act in XFactor history?

One word. Ray

I always felt Ray should have performed sat on somebody's knee

[D. Morgan]

Are threads like this a joke?

She quite clearly is not.

[Vol]

At first I was going to post that you need not even look to other years to find a worse act, referring of course to Frankie. But then I thought for a second, and the reality is that at least Frankie remembered his words.... and probably had more stage presence than Janet. I've now come to the conclusion that Janet probably is the worst act ever.

[Musicman103]

Forgetting the words to Mmm Bop?

[willywonker]

Originally Posted by D. Morgan

Are threads like this a joke?

She quite clearly is not.

Threads like these are always started by idiots.

[ForGodsSake]

She's one of the worst, I agree.

[Volcane]

She said on Xtra factor that she felt some sick coming up, and that's why she stopped.

[Contains Nuts]

Originally Posted by BinCat

Worst act in XFactor history?

One word. Ray

He was better than Eggnog, Wagner & Jedward to name a few,

[ForGodsSake]

Originally Posted by Volcane

She said on Xtra factor that she felt some sick coming up, and that's why she stopped.

hahaha believe that and you'll believe anything

[Musicman103]

I thought her initial audition (Your Song) was vastly overrated and couldn't understand why the panel and audience went gaga. A bum note facsimile of Ellie Goulding.

[helena123]

She's not even the worst this series, let alone the history!

[The Steel Flipp]

Oh come on. Janet isn't the worst contestant ever. Chico, Wagner, Frankie, that bloke that kept mentioning his dead wife, Eggnog and Lloyd. I can go on and on.

[staceyxxx23]

Wagner holds that title

Also your hate for her got boring a few weeks ago

[Vol]

Originally Posted by Musicman103

I thought her initial audition (Your Song) was vastly overrated and couldn't understand why the panel and audience went gaga. A bum note facsimile of Ellie Goulding.

From what I've been told, the audience reaction to her audition was lukewarm - It was made to look a lot better than it actually was with some editing tricks.

[D. Morgan]

Originally Posted by staceyxxx23

Wagner holds that title

Also your hate for her got boring a few weeks ago

The OP is calling Janet 'the worst' - not 'the greatest'.

[MadraRua]

Originally Posted by hehe

Yes I am being serious and there have been some awful acts in the past.

Really she is right up there, forgets her words all the times, no stage prescence at all, completely boring beyond belief, can't sing in tune and added to the fact she actually cannot sing at all!

The worst ever? For me yes.

God knows how she is still in.

The worst contestant in the history of X Factor would be Frankie.

Stop exaggerating. She had a bad performance with MmmBop but pulled it back with Under The Bridge.

[Musicman103]

Nobody has mentioned Jedward

[Contains Nuts]

Originally Posted by Musicman103

Nobody has mentioned Jedward

I did. Post 40.