Why didn't Perrie go through on her own?

2 of 2

PollyAnnaGirl

27-11-2011

Originally Posted by chezzle:
“I think we have to be thankful that Tulisa put through strong female singers for her groups, makes up for the terrible decisions that Kelly made.”

In what way? None of the singers from Little Mix would have made it as soloists.

badromancer

27-11-2011

Originally Posted by Kyle123:
“She's great, but wouldn't stand out as well as a solo artist. I think a group was the best place for her. Exactly the same thing was said about the awesome Phoebe Brown from Hope a few years ago. She shone in a group, but as a solo artist would have been really forgettable.”

Yeah I agree with you!

ArsenalX

27-11-2011

Originally Posted by chezzle:
“I think we have to be thankful that Tulisa put through strong female singers for her groups, makes up for the terrible decisions that Kelly made.”

I cant tell whether its indeliberate ignorance or you just like slating kelly, LM soloist were rejected during bootcamp stage first round I think, all four judges, including your precious Miss tulisa was involved in canning them too.

Kelly did not start to choose alone until judges houses.

Why is it hard to understand that LM soloists were not outclassed on their own and are better now as a group. In another time and place maybe they would have made it thus far as solos, but he competition was stiff this year. Sometimes its all about luck, being in the right place at the right place. They got lucky too to even get a second chance and now in top 5.

Gilrs like Jade, Nicole Simpson, and Melanie Mccabe, had what it takes to go far, but it wasn't meant to be , at least this year.

BrokenArrow

27-11-2011

I think its become more and more obvious as the weeks go by that Perrie is the standout vocalist in this competition.

newportjoe25

27-11-2011

Originally Posted by blowup:
“however, she did cop out a bit when singing the shiiiine bit in beautiful, she went into a higher register rather than belt it like christina does. I don't think her voice is amazing, and her look and tone reminds me of 80s Supercuts Dorothy.”

I'd just like to point out that Christina Aguilera has NEVER hit that note when singing it live. Ever.

shaunnashines

27-11-2011

Originally Posted by newportjoe25:
“I'd just like to point out that Christina Aguilera has NEVER hit that note when singing it live. Ever.”

Really?

Wow go Perrie, didn't know she had that kind of range. Gave me goosebumps

Salv*

27-11-2011

Originally Posted by staceyxxx23:
“Janet is a fantastic singer and underrated by many ”

I don't want to slate people's faves but comparing Janet and Perrie is ludicrous

Janet has forgotten her words twice in the show, in the space of a few weeks. And Mmmbop was probably the worst ever in the history of X Factor, and I count Jedward, Wagner and Frankie in that, and the most uncomfortable performance ever on the show.

Socialaddict

27-11-2011

Omg shut up people! Perrie is way better in Little Mix!

Leigh-Anne is so underrated! her vocal skills are mad!!
Just look on youtube at the the solo stuff she's done and you'll think differently.
Little Mix have four strong singers, and that's how it's meant to be!

shaunnashines

27-11-2011

Originally Posted by Socialaddict:
“Omg shut up people! Perrie is way better in Little Mix!

Leigh-Anne is so underrated! her vocal skills are mad!!
Just look on youtube at the the solo stuff she's done and you'll think differently.
Little Mix have four strong singers, and that's how it's meant to be!”

Jade is also underated.

wsidi

27-11-2011

As much as Perrie is a worthy solo vocalist..

I would want my Little Muffins any other way!

newportjoe25

27-11-2011

Originally Posted by shaunnashines:
“Really?
Wow go Perrie, didn't know she had that kind of range. Gave me goosebumps ”

Really.

But then Perrie didn't belt it either, she used head voice. Class voice on her though. I'd like to hear her solo.

chezzle

27-11-2011

Originally Posted by ArsenalX:
“I cant tell whether its indeliberate ignorance or you just like slating kelly, LM soloist were rejected during bootcamp stage first round I think, all four judges, including your precious Miss tulisa was involved in canning them too.

Kelly did not start to choose alone until judges houses.

Why is it hard to understand that LM soloists were not outclassed on their own and are better now as a group. In another time and place maybe they would have made it thus far as solos, but he competition was stiff this year. Sometimes its all about luck, being in the right place at the right place. They got lucky too to even get a second chance and now in top 5.

Gilrs like Jade, Nicole Simpson, and Melanie Mccabe, had what it takes to go far, but it wasn't meant to be , at least this year.”

What I can't understand is that so many comments on this forum result in personal attacks. Indeliberate ignorance?

I said something slightly controversial.

Course, if I'd have posted a picture comparing someone to ET or made a fat joke I'd have been getting big smiley grins and respect.

This whole forum is a joke I'm wondering why I registered.

2 of 2