One of the most talked about events of last night , it would only be fair to Carol to have her say either singing on one of the results show or as a guest on xrta factor

gary was out of order and carol should have her say

she was supposed to be on xtra factor via the phone last night but apparently it was "pulled" (Gary didn't want to go ahead with it)

but he's apologised to her on Twitter today and she's accepted his apology and more or less taken back her comment to him on Twitter about the Take That gig so it's all over now and they've moved on ... so no point in dragging it out (perhaps he'll mention it tonight just to put the records straight and move on)

Yes and the show phoned her I think, from what I read, he then decided he did not want to talk to her, what an utter coward.

he should think about what he says on live tv , before making hurtful comments.

carol should have her say

Just shows his spineless character.

I'm really disappointed about this -Carole Decker is as hard as nails, she'd eat Barlow alive - would have been great popcorn moment

Who or what is a Carol Decker?????????

http://www.metro.co.uk/tv/883003-gar...x-factor-jibes

th lead singer of t,pau, the lady who made the song "China in your hand" a hit.

yes, this.

Well I certainly liked Amelia's rendition of the song. Never heard it before.

I'm not sure the studio is big enough to accommodate her nose.

what a nasty comment to make!!!! im sure ur face is completely flawless..... unfortunately we will never know that for sure will we....... Ms Dekers looks are not the topic of conversation on this thread so why come on and make such a stupid comment?????

have you actually seen Carol Decker? ... she has a small nose (and always has)

http://www.virginmedia.com/images/th...er-590x350.jpg

As a judge next year, who sits next to Gary

LOL

Her nose? Whats wrong with her nose?

I think the poster must be confusing her with Barry Manilow

I must have got her mixed up. She's the one with the sken, I remember now.

Because I felt like it. Seeing as she was topic of conversation in general and all. Is that okay with you? Yes? Good.

Just made me dislike Gary all the more. He can be quite a nasty character sometimes. I would have loved to have seen him and Carol have a little chat.