• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • The X Factor
Best final 4 in the history of the show?
saz111
27-11-2011
Little Mix
Misha Bryan
Amelia Lily
Marcus Collins

Imo, the only other years that would compare would be either 2008; JLS, Alexandra, Eoghan and Diana.. Or last year. Rebecca, Matt, One Direction and Cher. I can't think of any other year where the final 4 have been so polished and diverse.

Little Mix > JLS
Alexandra Burke > Misha B
Amelia Lily > Diana
Marcus > Eoghan

Misha B > Cher
Little Mix > One Direction
Matt > Marcus
Rebecca > Amelia Lily
Green Goddess
27-11-2011
Sorry I do not think it is the best final, but that is my opinion, if Marcus goes I will be turning off as the others do not interest me that much, or enough to carry on watching.
DUNDEEBOY
27-11-2011
Its a decent final 4 but Marcus just is not very good
yougotthelolly
27-11-2011
Originally Posted by DUNDEEBOY:
“Its a decent final 4 but Marcus just is not very good”

I disagree.
saz111
27-11-2011
If you disagree, which final do you think has been better?
Green Goddess
27-11-2011
Originally Posted by yougotthelolly:
“I disagree.”

So do I, Marcus is the only reason I will be even watching had he gone tonight I would not have been bothering.
wsidi
27-11-2011
IMO Marcus is the weakest link. But otherwise, it's certainly a very unique final 4.
Unigal07
27-11-2011
Yeah it is a really good final 4.
rubyx93
27-11-2011
Are you for real! I do think theyre all okay but apart from little mix they just dont excite me or make me look forward to watching them next week!
kyrandia
27-11-2011
Originally Posted by wsidi:
“IMO Marcus is the weakest link. But otherwise, it's certainly a very unique final 4.”

Agreed. He was well out of tune last night
masterquan
27-11-2011
Maybe. 2008 should have been Alexandra, Ruth, JLS, Diana would of easily been the best.
Still think its better though for those three the drama of it was the best
NorthernNinny
27-11-2011
Even the ironing came first tonight. Little Mix and Marcus are dullsville. Happy to see either of the girls win,(more so Mischa B).
yohinnchild
27-11-2011
Series One = Steve | G4 | Tabby | Rowetta
Series Two = Shayne | Andy | Journey South | Brenda
Series Three = Leona | Ray | Ben | The MacDonald Brothers
Series Four = Leon | Rhydian | Same Difference | Niki
Series Five = Alexandra | JLS | Eoghan | Diana
Series Six = Joe | Olly | Stacey | Danyl
Series Seven = Matt | Rebecca | One Direction | Cher
Series Eight = Marcus | Little Mix | Misha B | Amelia

Series 1 had a strong top 4 actually... in fact barring the odd 1 act each year (MacDonalds and Eoghan) has been pretty strong
ll_Calypso_ll
27-11-2011
Definitely.

Series 5 was brilliant too, but Eoghan brought it right down I'm afraid.
phil5555
27-11-2011
Originally Posted by saz111:
“If you disagree, which final do you think has been better? ”

Perhaps you should do a little research Saz and list the last four from previous series so we can compare?

That way we can make a fully educated decision.
RosiePosiiiee
27-11-2011
Best. 2008 could have been the best had it not been for Eggnog.
GREATGUY
27-11-2011
I never would have predicted this group of 4 at the start of the competition but i would agree collectivley there probably the strongest group we've had.
pothuthic
27-11-2011
1D> Little Mix
Misha>Cher
Marcus> Matt
Amelia> Rebecca
yohinnchild
27-11-2011
Originally Posted by phil5555:
“Perhaps you should do a little research Saz and list the last four from previous series so we can compare?

That way we can make a fully educated decision.”

see post 13
masterquan
27-11-2011
Originally Posted by pothuthic:
“1D> Little Mix
Misha>Cher
Marcus> Matt
Amelia> Rebecca”

yeh no way is amelia better than rebecca
Hogs Head
27-11-2011
In every single series (up until now), there was always at least SOMEBODY who I didn't like and was desperate not to win.

Series One = Steve
Series Two = Journey South
Series Three = Ray | Ben | The MacDonald Brothers
Series Four = Leon
Series Five = JLS
Series Six = Olly | Danyl
Series Seven = Rebecca | One Direction

But I actually love every single act this year
Hogs Head
27-11-2011
Originally Posted by masterquan:
“yeh no way is amelia better than rebecca”

Sorry, I think Amelia is miles better than Rebecca.
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map