The most annoying thing about Louis is how is is obsessed with where they come from. He always says "I want everyone in Liverpool to vote for you" or wherever they are from. What about the rest of the country??? Why can't they vote for them too?
Worst Judge Ever
2 of 2
Most of you are out of your minds, Gary is irritating sometimes but do actually remember Sharon Osbourne? She was a nasty piece of work who had no idea of how modern music operates.
Originally Posted by Dirtyhippy:
“Most of you are out of your minds, Gary is irritating sometimes but do actually remember Sharon Osbourne? She was a nasty piece of work who had no idea of how modern music operates.”
“Most of you are out of your minds, Gary is irritating sometimes but do actually remember Sharon Osbourne? She was a nasty piece of work who had no idea of how modern music operates.”
But don't forget it's an entertainment show at the end of the day. Sharon was irritating at times, but never boring. Gary Barlow brings a whole new meaning to the word dull
Originally Posted by donbon:
“You can add to the list his insulting of Sammi and then getting mad when Louis made similar comments to Frankie.”
“You can add to the list his insulting of Sammi and then getting mad when Louis made similar comments to Frankie.”
Loui is usualy honest with his comments. I dont thinkit is unreasonable to say Frankie was a pretty useless singer
Originally Posted by Dirtyhippy:
“Most of you are out of your minds, Gary is irritating sometimes but do actually remember Sharon Osbourne? She was a nasty piece of work who had no idea of how modern music operates.”
“Most of you are out of your minds, Gary is irritating sometimes but do actually remember Sharon Osbourne? She was a nasty piece of work who had no idea of how modern music operates.”
I wasn't watching when she was on the show, but from what I've seen of her elsewhere, I don't like her one bit.
Originally Posted by Bob Evans:
“Loui is usualy honest with his comments. I dont thinkit is unreasonable to say Frankie was a pretty useless singer”
“Loui is usualy honest with his comments. I dont thinkit is unreasonable to say Frankie was a pretty useless singer”
He said that once, completely out of the blue, having saved Frankie in the sing off 2 weeks before hand, and telling him the week before after his performance that it was great and that he was pleased he had saved him! Hardly proof positive that Louis only speaks the truth!
I've found all the judges have flaws this year, but I don't think I'd change them...Gary (apart from with his own acts which, in this show, is to be expected) says pretty much what we are all saying on here, something we've been saying for years we want. Kelly is fun and is always constructive with her criticism. She doesn't criticise for the sake of it. Tulisa's knowledge is limited and that can make her look a wee bit daft, but she's passionate and obviously gives a crap about her acts and Louis...well he's Louis! He's there to yell back, to provoke the other judges and to put the joke acts through!!!
For me it's Tulisa or Cheryl. Tulisa because she hides behind this "big sister" act with her groups but her true colours have come out twice at least. Firstly, there was the allegations against Misha which were totally unprofessional true or not. Secondly, when she said the guy who left The Risk "couldn't hack the pressure", despite the fact that he was clearly upset about his decision. There's other things like her lack of musical knowledge and repeating the same feedback over and over. For example, when she told Janet on Saturday she could sell albums and tours, but then said on Sunday she was saving Misha for that same reason. Cheryl I don't need to go into.
Can't believe people are saying any of this year's when we've had the likes of Cowell, Cole and Sharon.
I think everyone is forgetting what awful judges we've had in the past and how much people moaned about them at the time, even Simon Cowell, I think Sharon Osborne used to make pointless comments at least Gary tries to make constructive criticism, I don't think he means for it to sound mean.
Carrying on from earlier post:
Simon Cowell - lacks genuine warmth.
Sharon Osbourne - lacks a volume switch (but is the mother of the very sexy Kelly).
Brian Friedman - lacks a reason to remember him.
Dannii Minogue - lacks the name 'Kylie'.
Cheryl Cole - lacks talent.
Simon Cowell - lacks genuine warmth.
Sharon Osbourne - lacks a volume switch (but is the mother of the very sexy Kelly).
Brian Friedman - lacks a reason to remember him.
Dannii Minogue - lacks the name 'Kylie'.
Cheryl Cole - lacks talent.
Louis is the worst judge - he never has anything constructive to say and there is seldom anything in his 'critique' which is helpful or astute.
Tulisa very often seems to have her mind made up before she starts and has obvious favourites, which she freely admits, but it does make it difficult if you are not one! I think this comes from her having less experience of different musical styles.
Kelly has the ability to be a really good judge, but only occasionally gives the contestant the benefit of a full critique - all too often she comes out with meaningless comments.She has a better knowledge of American music, so sometimes can be unfamiliar with some of the songs performed.
Gary is the best judge - his comments, although often harsh, can be spot on and he doesn't favour anyone in particular, he remains reasonably impartial (apart from his own acts obv.) He has a good over all knowledge, and is not stuck in one particular genre.
Tulisa very often seems to have her mind made up before she starts and has obvious favourites, which she freely admits, but it does make it difficult if you are not one! I think this comes from her having less experience of different musical styles.
Kelly has the ability to be a really good judge, but only occasionally gives the contestant the benefit of a full critique - all too often she comes out with meaningless comments.She has a better knowledge of American music, so sometimes can be unfamiliar with some of the songs performed.
Gary is the best judge - his comments, although often harsh, can be spot on and he doesn't favour anyone in particular, he remains reasonably impartial (apart from his own acts obv.) He has a good over all knowledge, and is not stuck in one particular genre.
2 of 2
