Beyonce has a rare talent indeed - a thin nasally sounding voice that is rare in its irritation of the listener.

Knew this thread would have been bumped for this reason. :sleep:

Kelly should have done this as a live performance: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eqUFTWi1pVg

Yes, because Kelly Rowland is trained a Gymnast and has had heaps of practice at routines like that like Pink has And that's not knocking Pink because I love her (seeing her in concert next year in great seats ) but how the hell could Kelly have done that?
Like another poster said, she's not as good as Beyonce (as aren't the majority of current performers around at the moment) but she was better than Cheryl, Tulisa etc

I am sorry but I cant see why people think that Beyonce is such a great singer. I remember watching Dreamgirls where I reckon she was sung off the screen by Jennifer Hudson. Beyonce has made the most of the talent she has by a good use of business and marketing skills helped by those around her IMO.

i agree.She was signed by her father Matthew Knowles, then now her husband Jay Z. Obviously she has always got "first choice" at everything and the best deals. Also Im a big fan of Kelly, but i dont think she does enough promotion for her singles and albums, except Simply Deep. WLTO and Motivation!. She needs to promote!

Personally I think Beyonce is a great singer but she's a better performer. Jennifer Hudson could not pull of a show with as much choreography as Beyonce. Neither could Kelly

I agree. I also think that she isnt helped by some of the material she sings. Not sure she is as focussed as Beyonce with her career, though she does appear to work hard and appears to have a nice personality. She certainly is no worse a singer than Beyonce.