Originally Posted by Sazaleeno:
“I mean also, Johnny Cash covered the song, did he get any flack for it, of course not. The song isn't sacred or anything.”
well no, but Johnny Cash is pretty much a legend lol and isn't (As ariella says) associated with the X-Factor.
Trent himself actually prefers JC's cover, but I'm not a huge fan of Johnny's voice. I'm interested on how the production will sound on it now actually, purely because I don't want them to 'poppify' the song too much. It needs to have a certain grit to it - which I imagine will probably translate well live, it just depends on how 'polished' they've made the studio version sound.
And re: being sacred, it is one of 'those' songs you pretty much do not attempt to do lol.

The only reason I'm happy about it is because I love her and the song so much ha. Again though, I definitely do not agree with people sitting behind a computer screen and slagging her off for it. You don't like it, don't listen to it! Simple as that.