Ooh I love this. Although I have to try and forget they could come and read this. How weird would it be. It makes me feel much more comfortable knowing we can't dissect now so much, as we rightfully know so very little.
Originally Posted by Bluestone:
“I do agree with the general point that the relationship meant that we saw a different side to Aaron and that played a part in garnering support for him.
However I strongly disagree that Faye is responsible for this or should somehow be credited with this.
Faye is NOT responsible for exposing Aaron's caring side. HE IS. If this was not in him, we would not have see it. Faye fell in love with him because of seeing this side to him. If he turned out to be an arse she would have lost interest as she did with Jay or she never wld have been interested in the 1st place.
He could have easily been a pig or truly have treated her badly in the relationship and then the perception the BB producers were trying to show could have been her true experience of him and he could have lost too much support to win.
There were times when even I as a Faaron fan, just thought aaron should cut his losses and forget about the relationship. Especially after the family nominations. Maybe most guys would have. Aaron's choices made a difference because of who HE IS. He choose not to focus on the outside world's views and encouraged Faye too.
When you say that his last week is evidence that he would not have come in to his own and was not better off without her. That i believe is an unfair statement because 1) he was only like that because of the relationship -so you're having your cake and eating it saying the relationship was the making of him and then saying that without it he wasn't a great character . The best way to judge him is how he was before the relationship. Without it he would have formed different connections with his HMs and would not have felt so lost when Faye left. He was already liked before the relationship started and I have no reason to think that he would not have continued to be like.
Also putting gift gate to the side and the first day of moping after Faye left, the producers still manipulated what they showed of Aaron. For instance editing out his dancing at alex and Tom's b day party after Gift gate or the naked bed fighting. He had his happy moments. Who knows what else.
When you say that ppl need to credit Faye for what she brought to him. I dont quite see it that way. Lets not forget that she fell for him because of what she saw in him and what he continued to be. Only he is responsible for that as is everything He did in the house.
That is my thoughts on the matter but I love a good debate.”
I wasn't trying to credit Faye with his admirable features... All credit to him for being who he is and sticking to it against the crowd inside and outside the house. That takes some balls. But I do think that those we love usually bring out the best in us... otherwise why would we be with them. I am still grateful to her for us being able to see so much more of him. You are right we may have seen this anyway, but I think it less likely. I think I wouldn't have got on with Jay and Anton and many of the others regardless. Faye ultimately has a good heart... and he rarely doubted it... and the one time he did he beat himself up about it big time. I think he has learnt she is fiercely loyal.
I'll go back to that time when he was saying it didn't matter what she looked like he'd still like her the same amount. She saw this as a criticism and was confused by it... but what an amazing compliment.
Originally Posted by
Heaven Scent:
“So you credit Faye with nothing all the credit goes to Aaron.
Faye stuck with Aaron despite kissgate despite her families dislike of him and despite his moods, do you not give her credit for that.
Aaron also fell for Faye because of what he saw in her and what she continued to be, a solid dependable young woman who never put anyone above him, unlike Aaron with the Alex fiasco.
Also a lot of voters liked what they had going between them and voted for Aaron because of the romance.”
BIB1 I'll give her credit for it... though on second thought I'm not sure it was much of a choice for her. She couldn't help herself... like she said early on she was strung to him in a way she couldn't explain. I don't know if she could turn her back on him. I actually think he finds it easier to deny his heart and follow his principles than her... she denied her principles because she couldn't not spend time with him or stop caring about him... at least not at those close quarters.
BIB2 This still confuses me a little... and can only put it down to a mixture of the way Harry and Mark had felt about Alex when they left, about her family not voting for him in F+F and his own rel with her. I think it was a little misguided or poorly explained.... but I guess that's the nature of what happens in bb. You are pulled and prodded in the weirdest ways.
Originally Posted by
psychmed:
“I am not saying Aaron was an uncaring person before he started the relationship with Faye, but I certainly think we saw much more of that side to him because of his relationship with Faye. It is impossible to speculate how much of the caring side of Aaron we would have seen had he not been with Faye, but if the first week was anything to go by, I doubt he would have shown much of it. In fact I doubt we would have seen much of Aarons emotional side at all, apart from when he was thinking of his son.
Aaron quite obviously likes to play things close to his chest. He is a sensitive soul, but deals with that side of him by withdrawing, not joining in, going into his shell. I believe that had Faye not been there we would have seen Aaron withdrawing a lot more than he did. Especially once Mark left.
I am afraid I disagree that he would have formed different connections had Faye not been there. Apart from Mark who didnt last long and in my view was never going to stay the full course. He did speak with Harry from time to time but said it was always him who sought out Harry for a chat. He had very little in common with the others. Anton, Aden, Jay, Lou, were just not his kind of people. Whilst Lou is a very pretty girl she certainly wasnt his type personality wise. Maisy is too immature. Alex reminded him of his son, so not close friend material. Tom annoyed him a lot of the time. So there we are, I struggle to see who else he would have formed a connection with. I actually think because Mark was a bit daft he reminded him of some of his mates. They all seem to be into the whole "banter" scenario.
I agree that many would have "run a mile" when seeing the whole family dislike, and in fact he nearly did run. He was after all a "flight risk"
His words not mine. I give him credit for sticking it out, but I wonder if he would have done had Faye not encouraged him to stay and in fact whilst she said more than once "wait until the outside" never really carried that through. Indeed many people in Faye's position would have walked after the week she had with Jem and the family vote situation. She didnt though, she battled with her sister and carried on.
I think Faye was the key to unlocking the depth to Aaron, otherwise we may only have ever seen the surface Aaron. In my view very different things. I am sure by what I have seen on here, facebook, twitter and the other forums that many recognise that we saw the best of Aaron because of his connection to Faye.”
BIB - I completely agree. I truly believe that we saw much more of Aaron's real self because of Faye. That is not to give her credit for what was there, but for giving us a chance to see it.
Regarding relationships in the house... I completely agree. I guess we are friends with different people for different reasons. Although I think him and Harry were good friends... Harry didn't seem very deep/emotional to me. Faye and Mark seemed much more like Aaron in this repect. I think A and H were more on a similar intellectual wavelength? We def wouldn't have seen the vunerable side of A thanks to Harry imo... I think him and Tom were and would've been close... but not to the same extent as Faye.
I agree with your sum up entirely. It's funny though that so many of us consider whether we saw the best of Aaron because of Faye rather than the other way around. There really is something special about him, I really respect who he is... it is kind of relieving to see in a person. Faye, I like... and I can see why he fell for her... but I don't ever wonder if he brought out the best in her.... (now that I think about it I do think he did) or whether we would have seen a more/less of her as a person if Aaron hadn't been there.