Originally Posted by The Difference:
“Mike Krukow and Duane Kuiper from the Giants' local telecasts during the regular season are working with Jon Miller and Dave Flemming in a four man booth for the team's local radio broadcasts during the postseason on KNBR, which I think has been the case in past years as well.”
I didn't realise that, so thanks for pointing it out. It's like that I'll be watching the Giants v Cardinals game tomorrow via MLB.TV and I'd have opted for the Giants radio feed anyway, but it's nice knowing that I can look forward to hearing from all four of them.
Originally Posted by The Difference:
“I can't speak for Rick Sutcliffe's work on MLB International so far but I did listen to some of his work with Gary Cohen, Ron Darling's partner on SNY's New York Mets coverage, during the first two games of the Giants-Reds NLDS on ESPN Radio (thankfully when that series switched to Cincinnati it was mostly on 5 Live Sports Extra, as ESPN Radio brought in Chris Berman who I can't stick to work with Sut). I thought Sutcliffe sounded alright when working with a commentator who IMO sounded a lot like Gary Thorne. I know why he's marmite and that some of his views (his recent ones of Melky Cabrera for example) can be a bit out there, but I like his upbeat manner, his familiar accent and intonation. I guess that might have a fair bit to do with growing up with his work on Channel 5's coverage of Wednesday Night Baseball and the postseason when I was growing up, for similar reasons I've never had a problem with Joe Morgan despite many critics disliking his work.”
I take your point about how familiarity can breed fondness. I don't particularly rate Jerry Remy as an analyst, but I really enjoy listening to him and Don Orsillo call Red Sox games. This was the duo that I heard most frequently when I got into baseball (and is still the pairing I hear most often). I daresay that if Remy was someone I only heard now and again, particularly if he was commentating on games not involving the team I support, I wouldn't find him particularly appealing.
Sutcliffe's main problem, for me, is that he's too old school and is unwilling to accept that certain aspects of baseball have changed since he was a player. This isn't a character trait unique to him - many ex-pros seem to think this way. If anything, increased acceptance of sabermetrics and progessive thinking within baseball organisations and fanbases has only strengthened this attitude that the ex-players are right and the statheads are wrong because they've never played the game. There is still much that a former professional can add as a broadcaster, but I find it disheartening that so many are so reluctant to even consider the merits of advanced statistics or think about whether the assumptions they've always held about the game might, in fact, not be entirely well-founded.
Incidentally, on the subject of Joe Morgan, you might be interested in
this piece by Russell A. Carleton that appeared on Baseball Prospectus in July (I don't think it's behind the BP paywall, but let me know if it is).
Originally Posted by The Difference:
“Dan Shulman and Orel Hershiser will be doing the World Series for ESPN Radio, they're currently calling the ALCS having done the ALDS between the Yankees and Orioles and the AL Wild Card Playoff.
Before he was appointed Indians manager, Terry Francona was scheduled to call the World Series with Dan and Orel and to also cover the NLCS with Jon Sciambi for ESPN Radio, but since his move back into management he's just listed to be a "guest analyst" on ESPN Radio's World Series coverage. I'm not sure what that will entail.
It'll be interesting to see if ESPN look to move someone into their Sunday Night Baseball team in 2013 in order to keep the three man booth they've had with various voices since 2008 going, perhaps someone like Nomar Garciaparra, or if they'll just settle on Shulman and Hershiser. I guess they'll make a decision on who if it's the former in the next few weeks.”
It's a shame if Francona isn't going to be fully involved in ESPN Radio's World Series coverage, but it is understandable, I guess. I was rather hoping that the Indians might not get round to appointing a new manager until November.
The Sunday Night Baseball commentary team is interesting. Bobby Valentine will obviously be available to return to the fold, but I'm not sure I can see that happening. I certainly hope it doesn't happen. As it's ESPN's flagship live baseball game of the week, I would imagine they'd look to keep the three-man arrangement. As for who fills Francona's chair, I don't know. I've never really watched ESPN's live Monday and Wednesday night games so I couldn't really give an informed appraisal of the internal candidates. Maybe they'll go outside the organisation.
Finally, Cubs play-by-play man Len Kaspar wrote
this for Baseball Prospectus today on the subject of 'Bringing Sabermetrics to the Broadcast Booth'. Kaspar and Bob Brenly are a pairing I really like.