• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • The X Factor
Amilia Lily shafted
<<
<
1 of 3
>>
>
imahottie
11-12-2011
So those voting results mean Amelia Lily was properly stitched up by the producers last week
Mr Blonde
11-12-2011
Exactly...she would have won...
yellowduck
11-12-2011
I saw this heading and thought it was a link to a video.....wasted my time getting bog roll and baby oil.......
Silent Scream
11-12-2011
Originally Posted by imahottie:
“So those voting results mean Amelia Lily was properly stitched up by the producers last week”

Kelly blew it for Amelia last night in the duet. Really stupid idea singing while Amelia yelled her way through the whole thing. Stupid stupid Kelly.
geraldinemaria
11-12-2011
I know . . if only . . .
Zack06
11-12-2011
Originally Posted by Mr Blonde:
“Exactly...she would have won...”

Not to worry, all the labels are probably in a bidding war for The Princess, and she'll be able to pick the perfect contract as effortlessly as one picks up a hamper in Fortnums....

Little Mix however, will be chained to Cowell and his devil label forever, destined for a glimmer of success until the next thing comes along and they are thrown into the flop bin with Leon, Joe, Shayne, Matt and Steve...

So when it comes down to it...I guess Little Mix drew the short straw in the end
Likklegemz
11-12-2011
She never had a chance of winning! Prob disappear in a year, two years tips! She didnt have massive support encr her voting results! She only won two weeks in the voting when she was voted back in and then the week following bottom two!
Blue Aardvark
11-12-2011
It's interesting that Amelia could bounce around so much between topping the vote and being in the bottom two that week.

Also the fact Janet had such an early advantage goes to show they really can elevate anybody they choose. She was equally as bad as Frankie.

The winning single must have been chosen early on or else Amelia was seen as an upgrade when Janet faltered.

I think it might have been a credibility gap too far if a reinstated contestant had won after an abbreviated campaign however deserving she was after the injustice of her elimination. Even still the sense of the victory going to a gerrymandered in house group hardly resolves the general whiff of jury rigged stage management.
barrcode88
11-12-2011
Originally Posted by Likklegemz:
“She never had a chance of winning! Prob disappear in a year, two years tips! She didnt have massive support encr her voting results! She only won two weeks in the voting when she was voted back in and then the week following bottom two!”

Janet smoked the others two, Amelia smoked the others when she came back, LM only won when Cowell and Tabloids got behind her and the judges started manipulating.
Gizmo_Duck
11-12-2011
The results show she should stick to ballads.
MARTYM8
11-12-2011
Amelia can have few complaints - brought back weeks after she was sent home and given two pimp last slots in her first 3 weeks which gave her a welcome back boost.

If any one was shafted it was Janet - 7 weeks never singing in the last 3, negative criticism (before she forgot the words), and VTs suggesting she was difficult. Despite that she topped the vote the first 4 weeks and was second when Amelia came back. But eventually the negative vibes she must have felt got to her.

Amelia was beaten fair and square in the public vote - so no complaints really!
trevvytrev21
11-12-2011
Originally Posted by yellowduck:
“I saw this heading and thought it was a link to a video.....wasted my time getting bog roll and baby oil.......”

Brilliant

Don't blame Kelly - blame the stupid first week twist. We lost 2Shoes!
saucy git
11-12-2011
Originally Posted by trevvytrev21:
“Brilliant

Don't blame Kelly - blame the stupid first week twist. We lost 2Shoes! ”

What a travesty
trevvytrev21
11-12-2011
Originally Posted by saucy git:
“What a travesty ”

Eeva you're well jel and being sarky or are as totes emosh as I am. So 'avin a nervy b I am.
Mart_UK
11-12-2011
If only she was there from beginning, she clearly picked up votes from the float voters (topped the vote with show must go on and china in your hands) but didn't have the fan base to carry to the end because of the 5 missing weeks.
ultron29
11-12-2011
She could have easily won it!!!!
Helbore
12-12-2011
Thought this was gonna be another thread about her and Frankie.
orcocan
12-12-2011
"Amilia shafted"? must be because of the ballids...
CloudyE
12-12-2011
Whats the could have won? She didnt because she couldnt. I am sure she isnt the only bad karaoke Christina A out there but she will no doubt get some session work and poor "soundy likey" jobs.
johartuk
12-12-2011
Originally Posted by MARTYM8:
“Amelia can have few complaints - brought back weeks after she was sent home and given two pimp last slots in her first 3 weeks which gave her a welcome back boost.

If any one was shafted it was Janet - 7 weeks never singing in the last 3, negative criticism (before she forgot the words), and VTs suggesting she was difficult. Despite that she topped the vote the first 4 weeks and was second when Amelia came back. But eventually the negative vibes she must have felt got to her.

Amelia was beaten fair and square in the public vote - so no complaints really!”

Exactly! Amelia also had the Pimp Slot in the final! If they'd wanted to shaft her, they'd have put her on first and had her singing The Lonely Goatheard, accompanied by an army of dancers wearing leiderhosen and a herd of real goats!
sweh
12-12-2011
I'm very thankful that she didn't will.
vicktrick
12-12-2011
Originally Posted by yellowduck:
“I saw this heading and thought it was a link to a video.....wasted my time getting bog roll and baby oil.......”

charming
SpiderMan 83
12-12-2011
Originally Posted by yellowduck:
“I saw this heading and thought it was a link to a video.....wasted my time getting bog roll and baby oil...... .”

Staring Frankie cococzzza.
neelia
12-12-2011
She was given an unfair advantage by being brought back. I quite like the girl (loved China) but that wasn't fair on the others
Teddybear99
12-12-2011
Originally Posted by imahottie:
“So those voting results mean Amelia Lily was properly stitched up by the producers last week”

Amelia should never have been brought back - James should have replaced Frankie.
<<
<
1 of 3
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map