Yes , it is and you liking him is why you defend him .Such is life .But your telling me my opinion is the strangest thing you have read in ages sounded patronising to me

I still think regardless of what you think that Craigs part he plays as judge and his holding off on tens when others give it is all part of his attention seeking personality .

But yet you single out Craig as it being the reason he doesn't give out 10s? Hence why I find your rationale to be strange.


As I said, I find someone thinking Craig not giving out 10s is because he's attention seeking and yet admits the other judges are also attention seeking, has a strange rationale. I didn't say YOU were strange and neither was I patronising.

I also don't particularly "like" Craig. I find he's the most consistent of the judges that's all and gives out 10s when the dances deserve to receive it. I also never said you couldn't have your opinion so stop being so defensive.

[ deleted , just cant be bothered actually

As I didn't see what you put I can't comment.

I responded to you asking me why I found your rationale strange that's all. It was neither meant as an insult to you personally or a suggestion that you couldn't hold that opinion so if you took it that way then I'm sorry about that.

When someone tells me stop being so defensive I back away straight away .Thats it,

Ps , thanks for the apology I didnt see it as I posted

I believe it's a misunderstanding that's all. When you said "It may not be your opinion but it is mine", it came across like you were being defensive that a different opinion was being offered to yours.

so ....anyone? which couple would you have scored the perfect 40 in comparison to the ones that actually got them?

Karas Rumba and Hollys AT , both deserved it in my opinion
I could watch Karas Rumba , the first one in the pink dress over and over again

This year or ever? I'd have given Colin Jackson 40 for his Rumba in Series Three. This year I would have given Holly 40 for her AS simply because it was so fresh and unusual and to her Paso Doble. I also would have given Harry 40 for his Quickstep and 40 to Chelsee for her Paso Doble.

well maybe i didnt explained myself in the beginning of the thread ...

Just list the dances and next to it who would you give the 40's

AS:
AT:
etc

Do you mean of the dances which HAVE received a perfect score did we agree with the judges and where else would we have given a 40 to those who didn't get one across the whole nine series of SCD?
Or do you mean who do we think, out of all nine series, should have had a 40 for each individual ballroom or latin dance?