I go hot and cold with Cheryl. Sometimes I think she's really great and I wish she'd come back, then I remember how smarmy she and Simon were together to the detriment of Danni a lot of the time and think nah, stay away.
Without Simon there on the panel though, I think Cheryl would be good. The only thing I didnt like about Tulisa was when she brought up all the stuff about Misha - it seemed unneccessary and unproffessional to bring that up on the live show, no matter the truth of what went on. Apart from that snafu I thought she was a terrific judge and would like to see her back.