I don't like either of them, much prefer Kelly.

If I had to choose between them though I'd pick Tulisa because she was a better mentor and is a better singer.

i do like both of them... at the end of last year i was abit fed up of cheryl being there tbh but now that she is gone i realise that she was so much of the success of the x factor, tulisa was the best judge this year but cheryl did have this aura which was amazing and a bit more star quality.

Tulisa is completely dull. I don't care how nice and friendly she is, I want to be entertained at the end of the day. Cheryl please.

Cheryl hands down but I doubt she'll ever be back

1. Simon
2. Cheryl
3. Dannii
4. Louis
5. Kelly
6. Tulisa
7. Gary

agreed it wouldnt work. it'd just seem desperate.

.
Tulisa for me.

Cheryl dropped UK X Factor in the blink of an eye for the big time fame on US X Factor..........pride goes before a fall, a flat on her face fall.



.

I prefer Cheryl. I don't mind Tulisa, but I'm not a great fan of her either.

cheryl all the way over this loudmouth desk thumping chav

Well the reason why i did'nt watch every show infact i barely watched it at all this year is because the chav Tulisa was there and the lovely Cheryl was'nt

I much prefer Tulisa. Of course she wasn't perfect no one is. What I liked about Tulisa is that she was passionate about her acts and wasn't using the show to promote her own career. It is also evident that she will continue to support her acts now that the show has ended. I also found Tulisa to be overall incredibly generous with her comments to all the contestants. Her feed back was mostly constructive. She may not be a musical genius knowledge-wise but putting that aside she was the best judge and mentor. Sometimes she came across but a bit too passionate which was quite comical.

Tulisa all the way.

Cheryl was downright awful... I'd rate her along with Sharon as the worst judges the show has had. Maybe even worse than Sharon cause at least Sharon could be funny sometimes.

Frying pan? Fire?

I didn't like Tulisa at all before this series and I actually got to see her away from N-dubz. Now I do like her but I do prefer Cheryl.

Who wouldn't want career progression? It's basically the same job and more money. Plus she would of had a lot of doors opened up to her.
Hell, she only made a brief appearance but now she's getting Hollywood movie offers!

that's a tad misleading

Before the series started, I was skeptical of Tulisa but I actually quite liked her even though she made a few silly errors. Overall, she is wayyyyy better than Cheryl plus she isn't a bad singer either...But I adore Kelly

Here

and I dont even know Cheryl that well.

Tulisa is a better judge than Cheryl


But Cheryl is a better judge than Kelly.

obviously, who doesnt?

LOL, quoted for the truth!

I actually like both of them but as a red blooded male that is probably not a surprise. Cheryl is better looking but Tulisa is pretty hot too and seems like a nice person albeit quite aggressive.

There is enough material on this thread to keep a psychologist going for months....transference, insecurities etc etc

Prefer Tulisa. She's a pretty girl. They're both quite manipulative, in different ways. Tulisa was obsessed with getting her groups in the final whereas Tweedy was dim eye candy obssesed with herself.

I like them both, but prefer Cheryl.

For me it would be

1. Dannii
2. Simon
3. Gary
4. Kelly
5. Cheryl
6. Sharon
7. Louis
8. Every guest judge there has ever been
9. Tulisa

Cannot STAND Tulisa, she adds nothing.