i reckon josh, melanie and chris would be good anyone agree?
final 3 x factor usa
Originally Posted by toribaynes:
“i reckon josh, melanie and chris would be good anyone agree?”
“i reckon josh, melanie and chris would be good anyone agree?”
Definitely agree that would be an awesome top 3
Without doubt. Loving the show tonight. I was not keen on either of Marcus songs. I thought Chris was poor on the first song but great on the second song. I thought Melanie gave a superb vocal on both but would like to see something more original from her. I thought Josh was good on the first song and sensational on the 2nd song which was the performance of the night. I would like to see Josh win, Chris runner up and Melanie Third.
i really want josh to win but i wouldnt be too unhappy if anyone of those won to be honest ive enjoyed the x factor usa so much more than our one its nice that they actually go for talent over novelty acts shame uk x factor doesnt do that anymore the best singers from ours were shayne leona and alexandra the standard this year has been crap (apart from amelia)
I'd be amazed if Marcus made the final, there's no way Josh or Melanie shouldn't be there so it would have to be at the expense of Chris.
1st Josh, 2nd Melanie, 3rd Chris is a safe bet imo but who knows!
1st Josh, 2nd Melanie, 3rd Chris is a safe bet imo but who knows!
Originally Posted by toribaynes:
“i really want josh to win but i wouldnt be too unhappy if anyone of those won to be honest ive enjoyed the x factor usa so much more than our one its nice that they actually go for talent over novelty acts shame uk x factor doesnt do that anymore the best singers from ours were shayne leona and alexandra the standard this year has been crap (apart from amelia)”
“i really want josh to win but i wouldnt be too unhappy if anyone of those won to be honest ive enjoyed the x factor usa so much more than our one its nice that they actually go for talent over novelty acts shame uk x factor doesnt do that anymore the best singers from ours were shayne leona and alexandra the standard this year has been crap (apart from amelia)”
I think we are running out of talent. The problem is they are doing the show every year. Perhaps if they did it every 2 years more people would come through.
I would also add Rhydian to your list - I think he was probably one of the best vocal performers X factor UK as had. Sadly because he was not mainstream pop not everyone got him.
Originally Posted by Dazzer1971:
“I think we are running out of talent. The problem is they are doing the show every year. Perhaps if they did it every 2 years more people would come through.
I would also add Rhydian to your list - I think he was probably one of the best vocal performers X factor UK as had. Sadly because he was not mainstream pop not everyone got him.”
“I think we are running out of talent. The problem is they are doing the show every year. Perhaps if they did it every 2 years more people would come through.
I would also add Rhydian to your list - I think he was probably one of the best vocal performers X factor UK as had. Sadly because he was not mainstream pop not everyone got him.
”
loved rhydian i forgot about him oops his phantom of the opera was bloody brilliant and how he lost to leon god knows
Originally Posted by toribaynes:
“loved rhydian i forgot about him oops his phantom of the opera was bloody brilliant and how he lost to leon god knows”
“loved rhydian i forgot about him oops his phantom of the opera was bloody brilliant and how he lost to leon god knows”
Its probably the only time I have been really angry watching these shows lol. To this day I can not see how he did not win by a land slide.
Originally Posted by Dazzer1971:
“Its probably the only time I have been really angry watching these shows lol. To this day I can not see how he did not win by a land slide.”
“Its probably the only time I have been really angry watching these shows lol. To this day I can not see how he did not win by a land slide.
”
i didnt like him at first thought he was up himself but grew to like him as the competition went on i liked his version of oh holy night as well
Originally Posted by toribaynes:
“i didnt like him at first thought he was up himself but grew to like him as the competition went on i liked his version of oh holy night as well”
“i didnt like him at first thought he was up himself but grew to like him as the competition went on i liked his version of oh holy night as well”
I think he was one of the contestants that really did have a bad deal with the editing. At the start they made him a joke with some silly song choices but he turned it around when he sang You Raise Me Up. Everybody that sings have done a version of that song but I think his was the best, He followed up with Somewhere and it was sheer class.
I was lucky enough to see him live on his tour at Birmingham Symphony Hall and it was honestly the best concert I have ever been too. He is doing well in theatre at the moment and have seen him in both his shows.
Originally Posted by Dazzer1971:
“I think he was one of the contestants that really did have a bad deal with the editing. At the start they made him a joke with some silly song choices but he turned it around when he sang You Raise Me Up. Everybody that sings have done a version of that song but I think his was the best, He followed up with Somewhere and it was sheer class.
I was lucky enough to see him live on his tour at Birmingham Symphony Hall and it was honestly the best concert I have ever been too. He is doing well in theatre at the moment and have seen him in both his shows.”
“I think he was one of the contestants that really did have a bad deal with the editing. At the start they made him a joke with some silly song choices but he turned it around when he sang You Raise Me Up. Everybody that sings have done a version of that song but I think his was the best, He followed up with Somewhere and it was sheer class.
I was lucky enough to see him live on his tour at Birmingham Symphony Hall and it was honestly the best concert I have ever been too. He is doing well in theatre at the moment and have seen him in both his shows.
”
im glad hes doing good as i said i did end up thinking he was the best and i agree its all down to the editing i loved his version of impossible dream as well
Originally Posted by toribaynes:
“im glad hes doing good as i said i did end up thinking he was the best and i agree its all down to the editing i loved his version of impossible dream as well”
“im glad hes doing good as i said i did end up thinking he was the best and i agree its all down to the editing i loved his version of impossible dream as well”
I think he will have a career in the west end. The main stream pop scene was never going to be his route. I see Shayne Ward is now in the west end doing well. Someone was on here the other night saying how he had failed but its not all about the charts. Making it in the West End is a major feat.
Originally Posted by Dazzer1971:
“I think he will have a career in the west end. The main stream pop scene was never going to be his route. I see Shayne Ward is now in the west end doing well. Someone was on here the other night saying how he had failed but its not all about the charts. Making it in the West End is a major feat.”
“I think he will have a career in the west end. The main stream pop scene was never going to be his route. I see Shayne Ward is now in the west end doing well. Someone was on here the other night saying how he had failed but its not all about the charts. Making it in the West End is a major feat.”
defintly i agree with that its a poisoned chalice to win the x factor and to have to go along with what the dark lord cowell says you have to do im glad shayne has done good for himself and rhydian at least people get to see how good they really are rather than covering other peoples songs
Think I will be on the net in the morning to check out the results. Will not be able to wait till tomorrow night lol.
Surely Marcus goes. There is nothing certain in these shows but it has to be surely....
Surely Marcus goes. There is nothing certain in these shows but it has to be surely....
Originally Posted by Dazzer1971:
“Think I will be on the net in the morning to check out the results. Will not be able to wait till tomorrow night lol.
Surely Marcus goes. There is nothing certain in these shows but it has to be surely....”
“Think I will be on the net in the morning to check out the results. Will not be able to wait till tomorrow night lol.
Surely Marcus goes. There is nothing certain in these shows but it has to be surely....”
il be looking as well! normally i cheat and watch the performances on youtube but i was good today and waited to watch the show tonight!
Originally Posted by toribaynes:
“il be looking as well! normally i cheat and watch the performances on youtube but i was good today and waited to watch the show tonight!”
“il be looking as well! normally i cheat and watch the performances on youtube but i was good today and waited to watch the show tonight!”
Your better then me lol. I only watched Josh sing Hallelujah lol. I read the report and it said how good it was so the temptation got the better of me lol.
Originally Posted by Dazzer1971:
“Your better then me lol. I only watched Josh sing Hallelujah lol. I read the report and it said how good it was so the temptation got the better of me lol.”
“Your better then me lol. I only watched Josh sing Hallelujah lol. I read the report and it said how good it was so the temptation got the better of me lol.
”
lol normally im on youtube first thing thursday morning looking at the performances but i thought id be good this week lol
Originally Posted by Dazzer1971:
“I think we are running out of talent. The problem is they are doing the show every year. Perhaps if they did it every 2 years more people would come through.
I would also add Rhydian to your list - I think he was probably one of the best vocal performers X factor UK as had. Sadly because he was not mainstream pop not everyone got him.”
“I think we are running out of talent. The problem is they are doing the show every year. Perhaps if they did it every 2 years more people would come through.
I would also add Rhydian to your list - I think he was probably one of the best vocal performers X factor UK as had. Sadly because he was not mainstream pop not everyone got him.
”
I disagree. We're not running out of talent, their just putting through contestants who are particularly diverse or distinctive.
There are so many talented people who get to Boot Camp, but are never seen or heard of, because they are to generic or non-fame-hungry to ever be seen.
