I would swap Cassie for Andy, Lloyd for Verity and 4 tunes for Voices with Soul, (their voices may well have soul but they sure ain't got the X factor)

I would swap Tabby for Andy. Verity for Lloyd but leave the groups as they are.

I would leave the groups as they are Swap Tabby for Andy and would swap Rowetta with Lloyd

My first visit to this forum! It's so quiet and calm in here..was expecting a riot like PI

I'd swap Verity for Lloyd........how she got in I don't know, yes she can sing but nothing spectacular!
Tabby for Andy and Voices With Soul for 4 tunes.

Andy for Cassie.
Lloyd for Rowetta
Odis for Verity

Agree about Lloyd - how on earth did Simon miss out on putting Lloyd through ?????

Agreed, other than I would swap Rowetta for LLoyd.

Rowetta for Lloyd.

Odis for Steve. I see Steves appeal but for me Odis was lovely.

Andy for Tabby (only because Sharon wanted Tabby through from the start and think Andy got screwed).

Don´t like 2 to go at all but don´t like boybands either so nevermind.

i would do the same as you!!!
Especially andy... i was gutted he didnt get thro

I would swap Tabby for Andy and Cassie/Roberta for Megan.

i am quite surprised that a few people want andy back, i thought people will be feeling tabby's rock thing.
I would swap anyone in sharon's group to have andy back.

i liked tabby too but andy was my favourite!
I dont think andy had the best voice in that group (i think cassie does) but i do think he came across as the one with the best personality (i mean sharon was in tears about having to tell him he didnt get thro') and i thought he sounded amazing in the boot camp audition, he even made terry cry
I hope he gets sometrhing out of this.

roberta for andy - sharon deffo made mistake here!! i want andy back..hes such a lovely guy
voices with soul for 4tunes
lloyd for verity - simon said she has the weakest voice then why the hell he put her through??its clear that llyod have a better voice with charisma

Personally I think Simon has a thing for Verity..u can just see the way he looks and talks to her.

I would also swap Tabby for Andy,
Verity for Llyod
The duo (the one with the blind bloke in) for 4tunes (that is the asian lads, isn't it ??)

I already think that Steve is a tosser
and i don't mind Rowetta being a bit "different" .

I would swop Tabby for ANYBODY else. BAD choice Sharon

Glad I'm not the only one that thought that.

I wouldn't swap anyone in Sharon's group, I like Andy but the other three are more talented.

Louie's groups I would leave the same too.

Simon's group, I would swap Verity for Lloyd, strange behaviour from Simon unless as Blue Eyes says, he has a thing for her!
Last edited by Kewpee : 17-10-2004 at 01:10

I would swap:

Tabby for Megan

Verity for Lloyd

and keep the groups as they are. (good choice, Louis! )

Lloyd for Verity
leave the groups as they stand
Andy for Tabby

helloooooooo earth to the Osbourne camp beep beep beep beep is there anybody there?

What the hell were you thinking Sharon picking Tabby over Andy?
I am quite sure she intended to put Tabby through right from the start,
there was a spark between them from day 1,maybe he reminds her of a
young Ozzy?
She is really going to be kicking when she realises how popular our young
Andy is, and if she had kept him in she would of stood a better chance of
winning.Dont get me wrong im not slagging Tabby off in any way the lads
done great,he just seems to of got to the final 3 on his attitude alone,
something sharon really likes about him,but not the majority of joe public
[ if i can go by all the other forums i have read ], and Andy was miles ahead
Tabby in the popularity stakes

SO WHOS SORRY NOW SHAZ

Andy if your reading any of these forums we think you number 1,and i bet you
the girls flocking after you now,and i am sure your phones not stopped
ringing with offers of fame and fortune.

Andy and family i will be down to see you all as soon as i can
uncle pete and family

I would definitely swap Tabby for Andy

Uncle Pete, I know you have a vested interest in Andy, but I agree 100% with you, as do 90% of the posters on this thread. I believe this will cost Sharon the competition too.

Though I agree with the main part of what Sharon said Andy would of won her more votes than Tabby any day of the week.
Mind you doesn't help that Andy was taught in college by a man who had no idea how to teach singing.
I'm no singer but I think with my time at Blackpool & fylde college I came out worse than I went in.

Judging by the consensus of opinion on many noticeboards, Sharon has definitely made the wrong decision in not picking Andy. I think she is going to face an uphill struggle with her three groups.

I would swap Tabby for Megan , I'm hoping Verity can surprise also voices with soul

I'm gonna break the rules with a 'cross group swap' here, but swap

Voices With Soul for Lloyd
2 to go for Andy