Would love your comments:

Nah, every judging panel needs a 'Mr Nasty' - he makes it interesting and stirs up controversy.

Yes I agree but do you think he's fair?

He is VERY fair and is he the only one to give true constructive comment unlike Len's 7's to everyone

keep craig, get rid of the other three jokers

Craig is my favourite judge.

His 'constructive critism/critique' didn't always match his marks tonight, I thought.

I actually like Craig and Bruno in equal measure. Without these two it would be Dull Dull dull.

NOOOO KEEP CRAIG unlike the others when he gives a ten, it means a ten

LOVE Craig

You don't post often - if you were a regular on here you would see most on this forum rate Craig highly - he's the best judge and a great character too.

Thank you for your replies, no I don't post regularly and I usually agree and like Craig's comments, but I just thought his marks conflicted with some of his overall comments tonight.

Craig has been great this series - I thought that his final score wasn't pre-signalled in his comments but otherwise he's been a-m-a-zing

So biased it's unbelievable

Definitely not. He's by far the best judge, unlike the others; Grumpy Len Goodman, who refuses to mark under 5 and has obvious bias against certain pros; Alesha 'you tried your best, have a 10' Dixon, who has single-handedly managed to destroy the value of getting a perfect mark in the show, and Bruno - can he get any more OTT??
At least with Craig the contestants actually know that if they are awarded a 10 they really deserve it - you'll find that most of them really yearn for that rare score from Craig.

ps I am a regular on here, just because I don't post doesn't mean I don't monitor this thread

I agree with most people on here, keep Craig. His voting is fair and when he gives high marks you know he means it, unlike some who give top marks to the dancers they fancy.

Craig is the only one who marks so that the celebs can be put in any sort of order. If we left it to the others there would be multiple ties every week!

I love craig . my favourite judge by far . always honest and gives dancers something to work on x if he gives a high score they know they did great ,

I post regularly and cant stand him

No, Craig's brilliant, an excellent judge and so genuinely funny sometimes. HOWEVER why didn't he give Chelsee 10 for her Rumba tonight when he said she was sensational. ??

don't think Craig is nasty, not like Jason Gardiner anyway. He is always truthful, usually the most insightful and the best judge in my eyes

Craig is the best judge. He does sometimes turn on the Mr Nasty persona but all in all he gives excellent criticism. It's the audience they should get rid of - or at least the people winding them up!

I like Craig and don't mind Bruno, but would be very happy if they got rid of Len.

Exactly!!!