1. Voices with Soul
2. Rowetta
3. Cassie
4. 2 to go
5. Steve
6. Verity
7. Roberta
8. G4
9. Tabby

1 Cassie
2 Steve
3 Rowetta
4 Roberta
5 Tabby
6 Verity
7 G4
8 2 to go
9 Voices With Soul

1 tabby

2 steve

3 rowetta

4 2 to go

5 cassie

6 v.w.s

7 g4

8 roberta

9 verity

1.Rowetta
2.Cassie
3.G4
4.Roberta
5.Voices with Soul
6.2 to go
7.Verity
8.Tabby
9. Steve


I think the overall standard is the highest of all the TV reality music shows.
In previous shows I've thought maybe 2 at the most, in any one series as 'exceptional' singers. In this show I'd say at least 4 acts are exceptional and the rest just 'very good'.

1. Rowetta
2. Tabby
3. Voices with Soul
4. G4
5. Steve
6. Cassie
7. Roberta
8. 2 to Go
9. Verity

1. Rowetta
2. Voices with soul
3. G4
4. Steve
5. Verity
6. Tabby
7. 2 to go
8. Cassie
9. Roberta

(Please ignore)
Last edited by LindyLupin : 18-10-2004 at 13:54

VOTING results so far (based on 21 people's estimated positions).


1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

Rowetta

7 7 4 1 0 0 0 1 1

G4

7 1 1 3 0 2 4 1 2

Cassie

5 4 2 0 4 2 3 1 0

Tabby

1 3 2 2 4 3 0 3 4

Voices FS

1 1 4 2 2 1 1 5 3

2toGo

0 1 1 3 2 5 2 6 1

Steve

0 4 3 4 6 1 1 0 2

Verity

0 0 3 3 0 3 4 2 6

Roberta
0 0 1 3 3 4 6 2 2

Thanks Lindy

You're welcome Bill - the results are interesting. I tried to send it as a grid and it threw the formatting out of line! So at least this makes some sense. Rowetta's way out in front. G4 not much activity in the middle, people either love or hate. Cassie could be a dark horse, with strong first and second positions. Based on this feedback 2 to Go and Verity aren't doing so well, with apparently Roberta least favourite at the moment.

why are 2 to go above steve?

how have you worked it out?

favourite
favourite
favourite
favourite
favourite
favourite

welcome to the UK!

Sorry Anne, I know I should have tried to put the order of names in their correct positions, but whilst it's easier with the higher scorers, I thought I'd leave it to someone with more of a maths brain to estimate the results, based on this feedback. When I had it all wonderfully set out as a grid it was easier to analyse, but I was seeing numbers dancing on my sandwiches, by the time I'd finished! I just collated people's responses in the order they were submitted.

ooh sorry for being picky Lindy!! I trained as a maths teacher and find myself analysing lists and numbers and just can't help myself!!

i am in the u.k thank you very. it was only a mistake

wow! great showing by rowetta...
really looking forward to saturday

1. Cassie
2. G4
3. Steve
4. Tabby
5. Roberta
6. Rowetta
7. 2 to go
8. Verity
9. Voices with Soul

However Andy should've been in Sharon's 3 instead of Roberta. Hope this isn't the last we c of him!

At the moment -

1. Tabby
2. Steve
3. Cassie
4. Voices with Soul
5. Roberta
6. 2 To Go
7. Verity
8. G4
9. Rowetta

1. Steve (fit)
2. G4 (different)
3. Voices with soul (go girls)
4. Roberta (wish i was that thin)
5. Tabby (get your hair cut)
6.Cassie (cute)
7. 2 to go (ok)
8. Rowetta (sorry folks)
9. Verity (pathetic)

Tabby
G4
Cassie
Steve
Rowetta
VWS
Roberta
2 to Go
Verity

Could change after Saturday.

Exceptional:

1. Rowetta (Wasn't convinced until she sang 'Over the Rainbow' at bootcamp - amazing)
2. Voices with soul (Three exceptional singers)
3. Steve (Again, wasn't convinced until he sang 'Dance with my Father. Amazing)
4. Cassie (Amazing voice, well done sharon)

OK:

5. Roberta (Good voice and look, just a bit, well, same-old-same-old
6. 2 to Go (Hmm, good voices, good harmonies. Nowt special)

What were the Judges thinkin!

7. Tabby - I don't get it?! He is crap! Does Sharon fancy this guy or summat?! ???? Still don't understand.
8. G4 - Oooh look, they can sing in posh accents in choral style. Tacky novelty. English public school toff version of the cheeky girls.
9. Verity - Wha?! Hold up! LLYOD MAN!!! Bloody hell Simon you noggin!

Programme Guide,

You may enjoy the "Pedant Thread" in General Discussion. It is an area where you are able to vent your pedantic frustration without pissing other people off.

Best regarrrdds,

LYW

ROWETTA ALL THE WAY!!!!! WOOOOOHOOOO!!!

here is my list

Rowetta
Steve
Voices with Soul
2 To Go
Cassie
G4
Roberta
Verity
Tabby

1. Rowetta
2. Voices With Soul
3. G4
4. Steve
5. 2 To Go
6. Roberta
7. Verity
8. Tabby
9. Cassie

1. Rowetta
2. Cassie
3. G4
4. Voices with Soul
I get a bit stuck here as I'm not really keen on any of the rest, but if I had to place them I would go for:
5. Verity
6.Tabby
7. 2 to Go
8. Roberta
9. Steve