• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • The X Factor
Who's Your Favorite! From G4 to Rowetta You decide
<<
<
3 of 3
>>
>
ZipGypsy
19-10-2004
Originally Posted by LYW:
“Programme Guide,

You may enjoy the "Pedant Thread" in General Discussion. It is an area where you are able to vent your pedantic frustration without pissing other people off.

Best regarrrdds,

LYW”

Well said. I can't abide 'correctors'. Or is it correcters....or correctars? Who cares?
Val
19-10-2004
1. Rowetta
2. G4
3. Verity
4. Roberta
5. Cassie
6. Tabby
7. Voices with soul
8. Steve
9. 2 to go

I would only buy two of their records: Rowetta and G4. So i will only vote for those two
ArtyAttack
19-10-2004
Originally Posted by Val:
“1. Rowetta
2. G4
3. Verity
4. Roberta
5. Cassie
6. Tabby
7. Voices with soul
8. Steve
9. 2 to go

I would only buy two of their records: Rowetta and G4. So i will only vote for those two”

Agree with your top two choices Val but I would swap the places round.
Nudd
19-10-2004
1. STEVE
2. Rowetta
3. Voice with Soul
4. Cassie
5. Tabby
6. 2 to go
7. Roberta
8. G4
9. Verity
Ena Sharples
19-10-2004
2 to go appear to be
A wannabe Peters and Lee
So they should go, and next should be
The sad pathetic Verity
And Cassie next, though young and pretty
Looks like Charlotte, what a pity!
Tabby, with his 'Sharon' hair
And kitten name will get nowhere
Next to go, I do believe
Will be the scruffy, flirty Steve
The girls with soul are next to go
The X Factor is not their show
So who is next? Must be Rowetta
She's quite good, but some are better
Roberta then, is number two
With looks and voice, she'll please a few
The ones now left, we all adore
The winners have to be G4!
ZipGypsy
19-10-2004
Originally Posted by Ena Sharples:
“2 to go appear to be
A wannabe Peters and Lee
So they should go, and next should be
The sad pathetic Verity
And Cassie next, though young and pretty
Looks like Charlotte, what a pity!
Tabby, with his 'Sharon' hair
And kitten name will get nowhere
Next to go, I do believe
Will be the scruffy, flirty Steve
The girls with soul are next to go
The X Factor is not their show
So who is next? Must be Rowetta
She's quite good, but some are better
Roberta then, is number two
With looks and voice, she'll please a few
The ones now left, we all adore
The winners have to be G4!”

Very, very well done. We are not worthy, oh Ena Sharples
ArtyAttack
19-10-2004
Originally Posted by Ena Sharples:
“2 to go appear to be
A wannabe Peters and Lee
So they should go, and next should be
The sad pathetic Verity
And Cassie next, though young and pretty
Looks like Charlotte, what a pity!
Tabby, with his 'Sharon' hair
And kitten name will get nowhere
Next to go, I do believe
Will be the scruffy, flirty Steve
The girls with soul are next to go
The X Factor is not their show
So who is next? Must be Rowetta
She's quite good, but some are better
Roberta then, is number two
With looks and voice, she'll please a few
The ones now left, we all adore
The winners have to be G4!”

Love it!
anneonholiday
19-10-2004
I want to be an ESAB!!

We love you Ena!!
chocopop
20-10-2004
The only ones I care about are these:

1. Steve
2. Tabbeh
3. G4

Yay! They are my top three and won't change. Steve to win!
threecheeses
20-10-2004
1.G4
2.Rowetta
3.Roberta
4.Cassie
5.Voices with soul
6.Verity
7.2togo
8.Tabby
9.Steve

Are Roberta and Cassie the only 2 that arent novelty or got a story?
ProgrammeGuide
20-10-2004
Originally Posted by LYW:
“Programme Guide,

You may enjoy the "Pedant Thread" in General Discussion. It is an area where you are able to vent your pedantic frustration without pissing other people off.

Best regarrrdds,

LYW”

Only get pissed off when I'm wrong, please....
ZipGypsy
20-10-2004
Originally Posted by ProgrammeGuide:
“Only get pissed off when I'm wrong, please.... ”

Or arrogant?
Mirage
20-10-2004
I can't say any of them make me want to say "WOW" or buy their records they may release. I have tried to put them in order of my preference. This will most likely change once I see them on Saturday.

1. G4
2. Voices with Soul
3. Cassie
4. Rowetta

5. Roberta
6. Verity
7. Steve
8. Tabby

9. 2 to go
shortysally
20-10-2004
1.Steve
2.Cassie
3.Voices with Soul
4.G4
5.Rowetta
6.Verity
7.2 to Go
8.Tabby
9.Roberta

Although my choices will probably change on numerous occasions!

Sally x
moogester
20-10-2004
1. Steve
2. Tabby
3. Rowetta
4. G4
5. Cassie
6. Two 2 Go
7. Roberta
8. Verity
9. Voices with Soul

Probably have a better idea about my least favourites on Saturday, that's when it will start getting really interesting
Give It Up
21-10-2004
1. Steve - loved him from the start and melted when he sang "Dance With My Father"
2. G4 - different in a good way
3. Rowetta - great voice even greater personality
4. Cassie - very good voice for her age (much better IMHO than Megan's)
5. Verity - sweet woman, nice voice, the one I least dislike out of the rest
6. Tabby - strikes me as a complete fake
7. Roberta - or should it be Robota? And she reminds me of that awful Lucy, the florist from Corrie
8. Two 2 Go - how did they get here?
9. Voices with Soul - no, I wouldn't dare express in a public forum exactly what I think of them
cgbrannigan
21-10-2004
1.G4
2.Cassie
3.Roberta
4.Verity
5.Steve
6.2 to go
7.Rowetta
8.Tabby
9.Voices With Soul
cgbrannigan
21-10-2004
Originally Posted by metafis:
“1.Rowetta
2.Cassie
3.G4
4.Roberta
5.Voices with Soul
6.2 to go
7.Verity
8.Tabby
9. Steve


I think the overall standard is the highest of all the TV reality music shows.
In previous shows I've thought maybe 2 at the most, in any one series as 'exceptional' singers. In this show I'd say at least 4 acts are exceptional and the rest just 'very good'. ”

I disagree. I dont think it's remotly up to standard with Pop stars 2. I think individually most of the final 10 guys could outsing any of the guys featured in this show and most of the girls in the last 10 could do the same. Short of G4 of course I dont think any of the final 9 here would have made it past the 100 if it had been a pop idol show. Off the top of my head I can think of two or three from last years final 10 in pop idol who could outsing this lot and have better personalities.

I'm enjoying the variety of the show more but until Rowetta gets kicked out I wont enjoy it nearly as much as I should (although I did say that about the Eric Cartman girl in American Idol 3 and she ended up wining the whole friggin thing!)
HOFF
21-10-2004
Originally Posted by cgbrannigan:
“I disagree. I dont think it's remotly up to standard with Pop stars 2. I think individually most of the final 10 guys could outsing any of the guys featured in this show and most of the girls in the last 10 could do the same. Short of G4 of course I dont think any of the final 9 here would have made it past the 100 if it had been a pop idol show. Off the top of my head I can think of two or three from last years final 10 in pop idol who could outsing this lot and have better personalities.

I'm enjoying the variety of the show more but until Rowetta gets kicked out I wont enjoy it nearly as much as I should (although I did say that about the Eric Cartman girl in American Idol 3 and she ended up wining the whole friggin thing!)”



PopStars 2?...do you mean PopStars: The rivals or PopIdol2?

There isn't anyone from PIdol2 that was talented above basic karaoke. Sam could sing but that was about it. Please don;t say that the nasally McManus is a great singer.

That Eric Cartman girl is propbably going to be the biggest star out of the lot of them...

...even bigger than Sam & Mark
planetf1
21-10-2004
1.G4
2.Cassie
3.Roberta
4.Steve
5.Rowetta
6.Verity
7.2 to go
8.Tabby
9.Voices With Soul
lostchild
21-10-2004
1. G4
2. Rowetta

the rest is nothing special
AngieP
21-10-2004
1. Steve
2. G4
3. Voices with soul
4. Tabby

I don't like any of the others at the moment, that may change when I hear them sing on saturday.

Angie xxx
Give It Up
21-10-2004
Originally Posted by LYW:
“PopStars 2?...do you mean PopStars: The rivals or PopIdol2?

There isn't anyone from PIdol2 that was talented above basic karaoke. Sam could sing but that was about it. Please don;t say that the nasally McManus is a great singer.
”


I agree. Outside Daniel, Anton and Peter (Keith maybe at a push) for the boys and Nadine and Nicola for the girls there wasn't one in the entire PS:TR competition that could get by on anything but their looks. As for PI2, where was the talent there at all? Yes Sam can sing but how did a guy that age become so cabaret? Michelle McManus is not nasally though, squawking is not a nasal sound.

The lack of talent left in the age group harnessed in PI, PI2, etc has been drained which is why there is only one good one in the final 3 of the under-24s. Probably with the exception of Two 2 Go (and as much as I dislike VWS), any others in the final 9 would wipe the floor with any of the PS, PS:TR and PI2 finalists (and most of the last 10 in PI1 and at least 3 members of HearSay).
cgbrannigan
21-10-2004
Originally Posted by LYW:
“PopStars 2?...do you mean PopStars: The rivals or PopIdol2?

There isn't anyone from PIdol2 that was talented above basic karaoke. Sam could sing but that was about it. Please don;t say that the nasally McManus is a great singer.

That Eric Cartman girl is propbably going to be the biggest star out of the lot of them...

...even bigger than Sam & Mark ”

I was refering to the Rivals. In Idol 2 - Fat Michelle is absolutly awful and shouldn't have made it into the finals never mind past week 1. Kirsty, Suzanne and a couple of the guys were fantastic singers.

And I am aware of Fantasia Cartman's success but, like Simons affection for Fat Michelle, her success is down to simons constant praise rather than actual tallent. Every week I watched it when she was singing her suuuuummmeertttyyyyyyyyymeeee song I just kept thinking....oh give the girl a lozenge for god sake...bloody painful to listen to everyone on AI3 was terrible.
<<
<
3 of 3
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map