Katarina Witt, definite plus on Emma Bunton. Louie Spence, maybe a minus on Jason Gardiner. Christine Blakely, a minus on Holly.

Just changed to what I think.

Minuses:
Christine instead of Holly
Louis instead of Jason
No Colin, Isabelle, Michael or Katie - most of my favourites last year!

Pluses:
Katarina instead of Emma
Sebastian Foucan
Sam & Mark
Lots of the female contestants have dance experience
The rumoured big new arena
It's baaaaaaaack!

Louis Spence? Really? What an annoying speciman.

I think it's too early to say. As for people's favourites missing, we got this last year and then they had new favourites!

Minuses

Christine instead of holly
No Colin, Isabelle or katie

Pluses

Katarina instead of emma, not sure about Louie but fantastic that the panel is better balanced in favour of skating
Matty G back & Vicky joining
Overall I think the rumoured line up sounds good

Plus.....no Jason
Minus....Louis Spence

I would prefer an all Ice skating panel of Judges rather than have someone from the world of dance. Robin is more than capable of commenting on the performance side of a routine as well as the technical ability