Louie Spence - A pleasant surprise?

4 of 4

TerryM22

04-02-2012

Originally Posted by Snow_Leopard:
“Sure was, what was Robin thinking? I think he should go and sit on the naughty step!”

Your so right, I thought Robin had lost his marbles.

*Laura*

04-02-2012

Originally Posted by Helbrown:
“Basically he is OK, but he has got a couple of calls totally wrong - Andy A in the first show, and Sebastian last week. There was no room for cheesy showmanship in Mad World.”

I'm really enjoying Louis on the panel and find that I listen and nod in agreement with most of what he says. However, like you the only time I've disagreed with him was over Andy and Sebastian. I'm particularly surprised he's so critical of Sebastian because I love his fresh approach to the competition. His performances aren't as safe and standard as some of the better skaters and I would have thought that would have appealed to Louis. However, in saying that I was pleasantly surprised when even he had to agree that Sebastian was better than Jenny this week. That was a bit of a nightmare choice for me as they're my two favourites.

Snow_Leopard

04-02-2012

Originally Posted by Lorelei Lee:
“Robin has a very good record of judging by performance in the skate-off, and given that Corey improved his performance and Charlene phoned in a disaster, I'd have gone for Corey too on that basis.

The above said, as long as I feel the judges are making decisions based on their personal integrity, it's fine with me whichever way they vote. I didn't agree with keeping Heidi over Andy A in the first week, but I was totally comfortable with the explanations all three judges gave.”

Robin's explanation wasn't much. As I recall, something about liking a little sugar!

Snow_Leopard

04-02-2012

Originally Posted by *Laura*:
“I'm really enjoying Louis on the panel and find that I listen and nod in agreement with most of what he says. However, like you the only time I've disagreed with him was over Andy and Sebastian. I'm particularly surprised he's so critical of Sebastian because I love his fresh approach to the competition. His performances aren't as safe and standard as some of the better skaters and I would have thought that would have appealed to Louis. However, in saying that I was pleasantly surprised when even he had to agree that Sebastian was better than Jenny this week. That was a bit of a nightmare choice for me as they're my two favourites. ”

I haven't liked his criticisms of Sebastien, but was very pleased with his comments this week.

4 of 4