To me he was far better than Heidi

disagree

disagree

Heidi should have gone, athough she had potential too.

He was more jazzy and snazzy, but not as good a skater and partner dancer, which is what the program is about after all

I agree.

Yes she did Mark is the one who really should have gone, but Andy did more in his routine than Heidi.

none of em should have been in the bottom 2.... the one from birmingham sorry forgot his name..... he was by far worse than these 2........

I thought Heidi was more controlled, whereas Andy was faster.

Both had potential but for me, Heidi was the right one to stay in.

I thought he was the best skater

Gutted for Andy, he was messy but his routine was so much more difficult than Heidi's! And he performed with a lot more enthusiasm. I think Heidi's a lovely person but she had so much less to do, it didn't seem fair

I disagree, i found Heidi very graceful and nice to watch in her 2nd performance

Exactly.

I'm disappointed he went, but don't think Heidi deserved to go either. Thought Mark should have gone.

I disagree that he was better than Heidi, but Kirk and Mark should have been in the bottom

Sorry Andrei was always my fav skater, glad he stayed in, but Mark was the worst he should have gone.

Obviously that other guy (from the duo) should have been in the bottom two but out of Heidi and Andy I'd have probably saved him. I just prefered him overall.

The point Kati was making is that he has more to do - she was right. i would have saved Andy

I don;t think wither one shouldof been, Heidies routine was much easier which probaly helped her vote.

I sent a vote for Andy and Maria so am gutted he's the first to go - I thought Robin would save him as his routine was far more complex

OK Mark was the worst

Between the two at the bottom it was a bit of a toss up IMO

Robin was influenced by Loiui Spence. Horrid bloke made it so clear he hated Andy A. For what reasons I dont know. Heidi was just being carried about, where is the dancing when one is being carried about.

Yes, I agree - I thought he was one of the better skaters of the whole group. He clearly had oodles of natural rythm, was fast across the ice & technically managed to get in far more than Heidi & a good few of the others.

I knew he was going though - after Heidi skated & T/D were gushing in their praise, whereas they were noticeably cool & silent after Andy's skate-off.

There must have been something else going on there, judging by their response, it looked like a stitch-up, plus Robin, as a skater, surely should have voted to keep him (I think Andy's original marks were higher than Heidi's?)

I can't believe he is out, my favourite out 1st week, it's never happened before and he came third on the leader board whereas Heidi came 5th. How does that work?

So the worst performer by a million miles gets saved, leaving a performer with potential to get voted off.

Damn, there seems to be a air of deja vu about all this.