all very Verity - Page 2 - Digital Spy Forums

all very Verity

2 of 2

ZipGypsy

24-10-2004

Originally Posted by Blandishment:
“Verity can capture the publics' imagination because this is her last chance saloon. If she won then it would be a real story.

This is why Voices With Soul have no chance of winning. There's no story for the public to hook on to.

Why did Michelle win Pop Idol 2? Because a fat Glaswegian no-hoper made more of a story.”

Crucial, crucial difference here. MM could sing in tune. She wasn't a nervous wreck. Auntie Vee was out of tune more often than she was in tune. She has no stage presence, IMO. From memory, the audience would go wild for MM. Maybe that had something to do with her being a fat Glaswegian

Foureyes

24-10-2004

Roberta was far weaker than Verity last night. Her voice lacks the maturity and honesty that Verity's has. When Verity sings "I Will Always Love You", I for one believe her; when Roberta sang "Superstar", I couldn't have been less interested: blando teeny-tripe, suitably discarded.

Satchmo

24-10-2004

Originally Posted by Give It Up:
“TWO, I think you summed up Verity's performance very well but the sad thing is that is how she performs week in week out. She never gets a song right from the start though she does manage to pick it up as it goes along. Maybe she might grow in confidence if she lasts a couple of weeks but she'll only be given so many chances.”

How can you know this when we've only heard her once?

Delma

24-10-2004

I thought Roberta was far better than Verity. I found Verity to be bland and out of tune. I was surprised to see her go through.

2 of 2