Originally Posted by cylon6:
“That's an interesting list.Thanks rzt. The recent Tuesday dramas on BBC1 tend to end up with 6m, but there haven't been many huge shows there. Why don't people like watching drama on a Tuesday in the numbers they do on a Monday? Increased competition from football on other channels?”
I think its partly the way the BBC schedulers choose to play their hand. Reasonably enough, they seem to look at the Holby lead-in and try to push on with more female-skewing, domestic stuff. But I think it generally leaves them with the weaker end of the BBC's drama selection, and a genre they don't really excel in. Mistresses, All the Small Things, Candy Girls, Mutual Friends, and now Prisoners Wives - is it me or would all those look more comfortable on ITV?
The few dramas that have done better on Tuesday have been those that play towards more conventional strengths like cop drama (Luther, Death in Paradise) and legal drama (Silk).
I did look in quite by accident on Prisoners' Wives last night and it affirmed my conviction that it was something I'd usually avoid: very straight and serious, endless scenes of the lead sobbing in a room, all-in-all rather vanilla and lacking anything that would get viewers to stick. Call the Midwife has warmth and escapism, Sherlock has verve and wit, Spooks had shocks and action, New Tricks has gentle charm. Prisoners Wives? I dunno what you'd tune in for - maybe more to do with my tastes, but things like that always seem to me lacking in the distinctive quality or attitude you can usually find in the best-rated dramas.
Originally Posted by SamuelW:
“Channel4's latest obsession seems to be fly on the wall documentaries. Has anyone else noticed how many fly-on-the-wall documentaries there have been on the channel recently? It's as if they saw the ratings for One Born Every Minute and said "we'll do lots more of that in any workplace you can think of". So since then there's been shows about midwives [One Born Every Minute], doctors [24 Hours in A&E], hotel staff [The Hotel], policeman [Coppers], paramedics [Party Paramedics], models [The Model Agency], personal trainers [The Fat Fighters], teachers and students [Educating Essex] and tonight they're launching Bouncers. Its all too much, and only a couple of them rate well anyways!”
Quintessential Channel 4. Someone in a big glass office on Horseferry Road decided about 18 months ago that fly-on-the-wall was "back in" again, held a "thought shower" to dream up public buildings they could strap a camera to, then rocked up at the Edinburgh TV Festival to claim they want "originality" and "something fresh" for their network.
I'm not going to deny that some of these examples make entertaining, popular, and in some cases quite excellent programmes. But it's typical of Channel 4 to dilute the impact by throwing 9 examples at the wall and seeing what sticks.
Originally Posted by
Charnham:
“well this is good news
Desperate Scouewives Axed, lets hope this is followed up by Shipwrecked (sorry Kitten), Sorority Girls, and Playing it Straight.
edit: ok its a rumour, but it would be nice.”
Talking of over-saturated TV genres - I honestly don't think there's as much growth in this scripted reality stuff as the execs seem to think. Only TOWIE has been a proper hit - Scousewives flopped, Made in Chelsea was so-so, and Geordie Shore only does OK because of MTV's usually awful standards. It's just TV people getting carried away by Twitter trends, I suspect.
More than any other genre, stuff like this desperately needs that oxygen of tabloid column inches. And with ITV seemingly pushing TOWIE to be an almost year-round thing, are the other basically-identical shows going to be able to fight their own corner? I hope not!