Does anybody else think that the Judges played their weakest members first and when worked their way up.

Voices With Soul, Verity and Roberta were all said to be the weakes in each catergory with Rowetta, G4 and Tabby the favourites from each.

If they go from weakest to strongets next week, the order should be:

Groups

1st - 2 To Go - They are good but the other two were fantastic last night.
2nd - G4 - They are good but don't seem to put in a lot of effort
3rd - VWS - brilliant last night and soo didnt deserve to be in the bottom 2

16 - 24

1st - Tabby - Too cocky in his performance and didnt sound to good either. God knows why Sharon's using him as her main player.
2nd - Cassie - Was one of, if not, the best last night. did extremely well considering the choice of song.

25+

1st - Verity - She is good but lacks confidence. Definatly the worst last night, but also had a hard song.
2nd - Steve - Was good, but nothing special. Might do better when his sore throat is better.
3rd - Rowetta - defo the best performer in that group. Did magnificently last night, was in the top 2 with Cassie.

Anyone agree?
Last edited by dudeuk87 : 24-10-2004 at 11:58

I agree wit you DudeUK87!

I've talked about this on another thread. It was also mentioned last night. Once the first three had sung the order of the others was totally predictable. So yes, I agree with you. This show is far too like the worst aspects of Fame Academy - the favourites singing last and the judges having the final say on who stays or goes, no matter what the voting/paying public decide.

It will change from week to week. Cowell is not an idiot, he realises that things need to be mixed up to make it interesting.