Originally Posted by Chris Frost:
“The Achilles heel with LPCM inputting like this is that the amps don't add channel delay to the signal. So any speaker distance settings and lip sync setting on the amp are useless. It's the decoding player that has to do this before the signal gets to the amp. Okay, you've got compatibility and saved £30 quid, but IMO it's too much of a sacrifice to lose the channel delay function in the amp.”
I have never heard of this before so did a search but could not find any reference to what you have explained.
All I know is it makes little difference to where you unpack the data, what you hear at the end ends up as PCM. To my ears there's no difference between Bitstream and PCM, I think this is the general consensus - if speaker delays were being dismissed by the amp on multichannel PCM, I'm pretty sure this would show up on some setups in some way.
There are amps that won't allow you to add extra processing like Game/Movie/DPLIIx etc when in multichannel mode, but I have never heard of an amp disregarding the speaker levels and audio delay settings.
I have heard amps blanking out speaker levels and delays but only when multichannel analogue inputs are used for SACD, never on multichannel PCM over HDMI.
I would be interested in knowing more if you have any reference to this. I know speaker delay is very important, it's the difference in a good soundfield or one that ends up sounding like a church hall.