Originally Posted by Butcher Bill:
“...The bond in my opinion is much stronger between dog/human compared to cat/human..”
Let me say that although I'm more a dog person, I like all animals in some way (I've been plagued by guilt because I sprayed a clothes moth the other day!).
To an extent my reaction depends on the animal - there is an outstanding cat that lives near my mother that I love, however my niece and nephew have the most skittish, unfriendly cat you could ever wish to meet. It's never been mistreated - it appears to be a trait inherited from its mother.
In general dogs do objectively have a stronger and more symbiotic bond with humans than any other animal. It's been scientifically proven that dogs have evolved from wolves in a way specifically designed to respond to subconscious human behaviour and in a manner that no other domestic animal has copied. For example dogs are particularly sensitive to subconcious facial expressions and their vision (IIRC) has adapated partly for this purpose. Some of their instinctive behaviour that has diverged from that of wolves is actually designed to attract human approval (I forget the details - but I recall something about the way they've evolved to respond to eye contact).
Even anecdotally I think you can see evidence of this - not least in the way that many dogs are wusses. I've known many more dogs that I could not possibly see surviving in the wild without human help, than I have cats. It seems to me that they have retained more of their wild survival instincts and that more of them could survive perfectly happily if humans vanished from the face of the earth tomorrow.
There was a Horizon programme about the phenomenon, which detailed a host of fascinating research and experiments demonstrating the way dogs and humans have a unique link and offering theories as to how it came about (IIRC one of them was that in the Ice Age when food became scarce, runt outcast wolves started to hang around human camps for food).
Of course this is a generalisation - I accept that there are some people who prefer cats and probably feel closer to them than they would to any other animal. I'm sure there are some dogs I would get on worse with than the cat I mentioned earlier, but as I say if I was forced to choose I'd have a dog.