• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • TV Shows: US
Homeland on Ch4 (UK Pace) - No Spoilers!
<<
<
121 of 141
>>
>
RecordPlayer
05-11-2012
Originally Posted by Noiseboy:
“Funny how people read characters totally differently! The pizza night line was great... of course it was lame, but she was clearly desperate to keep a lid on things.

I genuinely don't find her shallow at all, with the caveat that the entire world of political other-halves always seems a bit subservient to me. Nor thick either - her speech was terrific, especially under the circumstances.”

With pizza? They're not 10. I wouldn't even suggest that to my kids. I blame the writers.
Jess lives a blinkered, sheltered life and Dana is more sympathetic towards her dad then her mother is.

Sorry, noiseboy. I just don't like Jesse.
Casmana
05-11-2012
Neither do I! Only interested in being a socialate... and sex , not neccesarily in that order .
Virtual Paul
05-11-2012
I'm wondering where they're going with the daughter and senator's son storyline. Must be significant as we hardly see Brody's son.

[spoiler type prediction ahead]

When they were sat at the traffic lights it was just the sort of mundane scenario where something big happens in these types of show.I thought then that a hit against the Senator's son would be a likely retribution after what happened to the terrorist guy's son, and makes ironic sense if Brody's daughter gets caught up in it. That would really screw with Brody if he helped it happen.
Noiseboy
05-11-2012
Originally Posted by Casmana:
“Neither do I! Only interested in being a socialate... and sex , not neccesarily in that order .”

But... that's just... I... *sigh* nevermind
Denley
06-11-2012
Originally Posted by elgransenor1:
“makes you lose faith in brody as character if he gets turned so easily.

wonder who he'll get turned by next, mossad? ”

Was he turned easily? Has he been turned at all? Sticking to his I didn't wear a vest story would get him nowhere with that video against him. Turned or not, taking the CIA way out was a no brainer.

Originally Posted by MrSuper:
“Wow. That Carrie/Brody interrogation scene was a masterclass in acting. Superb.”

Originally Posted by Unigal07:
“Absolutely. Stunning scene.”

Yep, brilliant scene to watch, and great to see a drama have the confidence in its two leads to play it out as they did.

Originally Posted by RM83:
“My overall impression of this episode is 'wow!'

What amazing TV. It is understandable to want to talk about plot details but for me, the extended scene between carrie and brody made the episode, and the series. Even if the show jumps the shark from here on in, it can't take away the fact that this was such a satisfying payoff of the relationship between the 2 main characters and cleverly mirrored past events, right down to the final scene of carrie onher own.

Making brody a double agent was the only real way to go. He was never an out and out baddie in season 1. We were supposed to sympathise with him. Now we can again. I can't wait to see whay happens when they try to trace the tailor or when he has to meet with Roya again. I was a bit suspicious of her character up until now. Too much of a 24 style baddie but now I u derstand why the writers have created an obvious 'villain' to replace Walker.

Edit - i started writing this message before the above one was posted. Glad to see others feel the same about this superb episode.”

I agree and the ambiguity around Brody that made series 1 is now back. Which way will Brody go? He's not safe either from retribution from Abu Nazir or his own Country's vengeance against a traitor. Caught between a rock and a hard place if ever there was one.

We're thankfully being drawn away from a (imo) dubious Brody as terrorist VP plot line and deliciously back to the world of Abu Nazir's terrorist network, CIA moles & Roya.

Who knows what sympathies we'll find yet for her? This series has been great at leading us into thinking one way about a character one ep before flipping our take on them the next. And it's great to know Aileen's story has to be revisited.

and the can of worms that is Prince Farid & his major domo, Latif Bin Walid surely also has to be re-opened?
Denley
06-11-2012
Originally Posted by RM83:
“A particularly interesting analysis of this episode in this week's guardian blog. http://www.guardian.co.uk/tv-and-rad...o-episode-five

I particularly agree with the 24 comparison re. Dana's accident.

A question. Some of the comments are still tlking about the 'Mole'. Has that issue been cleared up? I'm assuming that Brody was responsible for the razor blade episode and that he cheated the lie detector test. Are there other unexplained info leaks that point to a mole?”

Originally Posted by barnsleykeith:
“Raqim got a call warning him the CIA was tailing him in Season 1. That didn't come from Brody.”

The phone call warning Aileen to roll out the US flag was the biggee. And the warning they got to run....

And the timing of Lynne's murder, coincidence it happened just after she'd been acknowledged and identified as an asset in a CIA meeting??

In that meeting they were told of Lynne's intention to download the Prince's details. And when downloaded those details were clean and shortly after Lynne was a gonner.
Denley
06-11-2012
Originally Posted by catsitter:
“Why don't the CIA just bring Roya in and interrogate her to find out what the plan is?”

She'll also have diplomatic immunity wouldn't she?

Originally Posted by MrSuper:
“That was very telling wasn't it? Seeing her picture on the board means we'll be seeing her sooner rather than later. We never did find out what happened to her.”

Very telling I hope, yes.

Originally Posted by barnsleykeith:
“Brody reminded me of a little lost boy looking at his mum for direction. Was Carrie totally playing him? I think she was. Being ruthless to exploit his weakness, with just the right amount of truth in there to make it seem real.

Brody goes home to his (pretend) perfect family and Carrie end the episode like crazy old cat lady, without the cats.”

I think Carrie was definitely trying to play him. But Brody's not stupid and could have worked out the options himself - ie prison/death sentence/gitmo or CIA double agent and rat on Abu Nazir's terror cell. Brody's played her just as easily in the past.

Originally Posted by Noiseboy:
“I think it's already been linked, but the Guardian blog on this ep is very good - http://www.guardian.co.uk/tv-and-rad...o-episode-five . Rather embarrassingly, I hadn't clocked their main point - that potentially we're right back to "is he / isn't he" of series 1. Given that Brody passed a lie detector test in series 1... are we REALLY sure that he's on side?”

I'm not, no. Him being turned was as easy a choice for Brody to make as they come in those circumstances. The difficult bit for him is going to be performing the balancing act to keep Abu Nazir and the CIA both happy. If he can't, either way it goes, his kids will pay the price for his mistakes.
Denley
06-11-2012
Originally Posted by mel_drew:
“As we're watching at UK pace, it's hard to tell whether or not you're missing anything. Last nights hit and run has to have some eventual relevance to the main plot, surely?

(Mind you, I speak as one who thought that a polar bear on a tropical island was going to be an important plot point! )”

I'm guessing Brody will find out all about it from Dana soon - poor girl will be traumatised - and it could be a handy bit of blackmail material for someone to use on Walden....

Originally Posted by catsitter:
“If there really is a CIA mole, then won't s/he get the word out to Nazir about Brody working with the CIA? And I do think there is a mole, not just Brody, because of that phone call in season one.”

I thought the idea was to keep those in the know as a tight group but I've got my suspicions who the mole is now.

Originally Posted by RecordPlayer:
“I think Carrie fell for Brody when she first started observing him at his home, on the surveillance cameras...
She understood him, what he'd been through and how difficult it was for him to adjust to his new found freedom.
Carrie had the advantage over Brody by studying him. He was just lonely and accepted her understanding him.
I'm not sure how much he likes her though.
I'm intrigued to find out where this relationship is heading....”

I've never been convinced she's fallen for him but I can understand the empathy she feels towards him and how she's vulnerable emotionally. She's definitely got a weird mix of hate and affection going on for Brody.

The scenes with them both in have always been electric, whatever their relationship. They do feed brilliantly off each other as actors.
Denley
06-11-2012
Estes and Saul have ruled themselves out of being moley now for me - Estes was in the bunker himself and Saul's been upfront with the suicide vid.

I've got a growing feeling Virgil is the mole... He's off grid but is so close to Carrie and her big gob.

He's always Carrie's first choice go to surveillance man. He could have deliberately not bugged Brody's garage and not just run out of time/equipment to do it.

He was around spilling tea or whatever over Lynne which allowed Carrie to pass her the compact. But when she was passing that on, Virgil could have explained all about the plan to Farid's major domo, Latif Bin Walid.

So the CIA get no useful info from the Prince's phone while knowing Lynne has no back up, she gets dead.

Carrie asked him to get onto Raquim's trail quick smart before he and Aileen slipped away, he could have got word to them then, as well as with the flag phone call earlier...hmmm.

The only thing I'm struggling with the razor blade but that probably was Brody after all.
solare
06-11-2012
I wondered about Virgil too (or perhaps his brother Max) - but surely he would have informed Brody that he was under surveillence. When Brody eventually found out (from Carrie at the cabin) he seemed genuinely shocked.

Perhaps there isn't a mole in the CIA but rather someone linked to Nazir's organization is able to bug/monitor their communications. The CIA does seem to be rather relaxed regarding security.
CD93
06-11-2012
I still don't trust Danny Galvez. He's the type of character you think isn't important enough to turn, but then you remember who created this show. I expect every episode to end back at the CIA, with Galvez in the shadows, on the phone to Nazir - or something

That said, however, he was in the car with Carrie when Aileen got the warning

Quote:
“Perhaps there isn't a mole in the CIA but rather someone linked to Nazir's organization is able to bug/monitor their communications. The CIA does seem to be rather relaxed regarding security.”

Seems legit.
catsitter
06-11-2012
Originally Posted by Denley:
“She'll also have diplomatic immunity wouldn't she?
”

She's (Roya) a journalist; I don't see why that would give her diplomatic immunity?
gomezz
06-11-2012
Originally Posted by Denley:
“Saul's been upfront with the suicide vid.”

That could be part of a plan to divert attention from something else going on or from someone else if they are using Brody as a screen.
Craigywageybaby
06-11-2012
Originally Posted by mychmose:
“I am going to speak in general non-spoiler terms here and am sure I'm not revealing anything about last night's episode.

I just don't get Carrie's relationship with and fondness for Brodie. It seemed unlikely at the time it started and it seems the same now. It affects my enjoyment of an otherwise excellent show, especially as it seems to be one of the central storyline themes.

Oh and another thing, I record this show and fast forward through the scenes that just involve the kids. It reverts to teen show style at that point for me. Hope I am not missing any important plot nuances!!”

I thought she explained her fondness for Brodie pretty well when she said something along the line of "it felt right". You've got to remember that Carrie is very troubled, her mental illness, her tendacy to go to bars for just sex etc. She's probably never felt personal connection with someone in that way, ever or for a long long time.
Craigywageybaby
06-11-2012
Now Brody has the CIA's 'trust', he's potentially in a better position if he's still going to be working for Nasir.

Not sure how he going to explain the knifewound though!?
Casmana
06-11-2012
Brody's never been the sharpest knife in the box has he ?He seems to bumble his way along from one crisis to the next..... how he's going to play this dual role out ....?
Denley
06-11-2012
Originally Posted by catsitter:
“She's (Roya) a journalist; I don't see why that would give her diplomatic immunity?”

oh is she I thought she was tied to some Embassy or other - why did I think that?

As you were.
Denley
06-11-2012
Originally Posted by Casmana:
“Brody's never been the sharpest knife in the box has he ?He seems to bumble his way along from one crisis to the next..... how he's going to play this dual role out ....?”

Perhaps he is best suited to stay in politics after all.
minkski
06-11-2012
I always thought that it was Brody who passed on the razor blade

I would have thought that the CIA would have sent in a covert search squad under the guise of something else to do a search of Brody's house and look for the suicide vest, the moment he was arrested.
feeVerte
06-11-2012
Brody left the vest in the toilette, they wont find it till next major emergency
minkski
06-11-2012
Originally Posted by feeVerte:
“Brody left the vest in the toilette, they wont find it till next major emergency”


I couldn't remember what happened to it- I thought he packed it away in the wardrobe at home

There would still be his prayer mat and Qur'an to find (bearing in mind he was denying his conversion to Islam)
mintchocchip
06-11-2012
I'm quite surprised to read how disliked Jess seems to be. She does have her selfish moments but she did have Brodie back as her husband at a time when she could easily have said 'You've been gone years, and i've moved on.' I get the impression she is really trying to understand him and make their marriage work. i find her quite a sympathetic character as I couldn't put up with Brodie's (from her POV) odd behaviour myself! The actress playing her has also been consistently good but consistently overlooked. She was fantastic in the scene with The Qu'ran the other week.
Smokeychan1
06-11-2012
Originally Posted by mintchocchip:
“I'm quite surprised to read how disliked Jess seems to be. She does have her selfish moments but she did have Brodie back as her husband at a time when she could easily have said 'You've been gone years, and i've moved on.' I get the impression she is really trying to understand him and make their marriage work. i find her quite a sympathetic character as I couldn't put up with Brodie's (from her POV) odd behaviour myself! The actress playing her has also been consistently good but consistently overlooked. She was fantastic in the scene with The Qu'ran the other week.”

It was a great scene, no complaints about the actress there. It didn't put the character in such a good light though...but I explained the reasons for my feelings about Jess a page or two ago, mustn't go on

It is quite ironic that the damaged characters who aren't so perfect and sometimes downright dangerous are the ones who get our empathy. But that's the crux of the show isn't it? If you can't find sympathy for Brody and/or Carrie it just wouldn't work; he'd be a regular bad guy and she'd be a total fruitcase. Not liking Jess the character doesn't really hurt in the greater scheme of things.

@Denby. Gosh, you have great memory - I'm in awe.
mintchocchip
06-11-2012
Originally Posted by Smokeychan1:
“It was a great scene, no complaints about the actress there. It didn't put the character in such a good light though...but I explained the reasons for my feelings about Jess a page or two ago, mustn't go on

It is quite ironic that the damaged characters who aren't so perfect and sometimes downright dangerous are the ones who get our empathy. But that's the crux of the show isn't it? If you can't find sympathy for Brody and/or Carrie it just wouldn't work; he'd be a regular bad guy and she'd be a total fruitcase. Not liking Jess the character doesn't really hurt in the greater scheme of things.

@Denby. Gosh, you have great memory - I'm in awe.”

I have empathised with all the characters and their positions at some point, even Estes! It's what makes the show work, I agree. That said, my sympathy for Brodie and his plight has ebbed away a little since he snapped that bloke's neck!
Smokeychan1
06-11-2012
Originally Posted by mintchocchip:
“I have empathised with all the characters and their positions at some point, even Estes! It's what makes the show work, I agree. That said, my sympathy for Brodie and his plight has ebbed away a little since he snapped that bloke's neck!”

Ha, I hated that episode so much I have erased it from my mind, which is probably why I relate it less to Brody and more to "who the hell decided that would be a good idea??". It was venturing into Desperate Housewives territory in its silliness. So much so I still can't believe they allowed the simultaneous neck twist, chat to wife on phone to be aired. It certainly took multi-tasking to the next level
<<
<
121 of 141
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map