Originally Posted by Servalan:
“Who says that criticism is ill-informed? Or are you John Yorke in disguise?
You may describe Yorke as 'passionate' about EastEnders. Others would call it obsessed with the show, to the extent that those employed in senior positions are now under such scrutiny that Yorke might as well just do those jobs himself. When he was briefly at Channel 4, his meetings there would be dominated by him complaining about what had happened to EastEnders in his absence. Which says rather a lot.
As others have said, Kirkwood came to EastEnders as a hot ticket and man of the moment. I would suspect he had a damn sight more freedom at Lime Pictures than he did at the BBC - so I wouldn't be so quick to blame him from every failure.
Yorke's continued presence on EastEnders will be the undoing of the show. He may well have had success on the show in the past - I wouldn't dispute that for a moment - but nobody can continue doing the same job in television without going stale. He needs a new challenge - away from EastEnders - and the show needs revitalising ... without him.”
“Who says that criticism is ill-informed? Or are you John Yorke in disguise?

You may describe Yorke as 'passionate' about EastEnders. Others would call it obsessed with the show, to the extent that those employed in senior positions are now under such scrutiny that Yorke might as well just do those jobs himself. When he was briefly at Channel 4, his meetings there would be dominated by him complaining about what had happened to EastEnders in his absence. Which says rather a lot.
As others have said, Kirkwood came to EastEnders as a hot ticket and man of the moment. I would suspect he had a damn sight more freedom at Lime Pictures than he did at the BBC - so I wouldn't be so quick to blame him from every failure.
Yorke's continued presence on EastEnders will be the undoing of the show. He may well have had success on the show in the past - I wouldn't dispute that for a moment - but nobody can continue doing the same job in television without going stale. He needs a new challenge - away from EastEnders - and the show needs revitalising ... without him.”
"Ill-informed" was a polite way of describing the waffle I'd read on here.
As for any comments at C4 meetings, perhaps working at C4 was less satisfying than working on the biggest show on the UK's biggest channel?
As for the "hot ticket" thing, not everyone thought that way. I certainly didn't. I had a bad feeling about Kirkwood's appointment. I was worried he'd leave the show in a worse state than he found it...



