Originally Posted by iseloid:
“Well, XF has nothing to do with it, the public and simon cowell do. You know there are many brilliant singers who lose out on XF and aren't put through over those who can sing. It's not what's wrong with the shows at ALL. You don't always need years of training, if you naturally have it, then it shows. If not, then we all find out.”
I just disagree with the whole premise of the Cowell shows. It promotes a rapid rise to fame - supported and backed up by very little else - for very little 'real' work in return, in my view. It gives false hope to those taking part and provides a bad model (money for very little/no work) for the many children who watches his shows, which in my opinion, is a negative.
The 'Ollie episode' last night proves that the process is flawed. Years of hard graft and training can never be replaced by instant fame, in my view.
The only winner of the Cowell shows is Cowell himself.