The X Factor ~ Official Live Show Thread ~ Sat 30th October (30/10/04) - ITV1 @ 6pm ~

11 of 24

thms

30-10-2004

it is so tough

fortunately g4 were laughable tonight

Ruby_

30-10-2004

I gave Steve the benefit of the doubt last week, but I can't say he sounds very different without the laryngitis. Nice guy, he's really not the best singer out there.

ArtyAttack

30-10-2004

Simon has played a blinder with that choir. Not sure how fair it is though. Good on Louis but he forgot about Tabby.

metafis

30-10-2004

Didnlt like Steve much, didnt do anything for me

tally

30-10-2004

Originally Posted by tigerlilyxxxxx:
“Michael and i agree ”

Me too,

, except someone said he looked liked Tim Henman! not a compliment.

thms

30-10-2004

sharon that was rubbish!

shocking in fact

Mirage

30-10-2004

Sorry, Steve didn't do anything for me.

Ruby_

30-10-2004

Sharon waaaay overstepped the mark with that comment. "You're not black, you've got no soul." Totally out of order - and racist in my view.

Sara & Emma

30-10-2004

You don't have to be black to be a soul singer you silly moo!

Sara.

thms

30-10-2004

steve sang that.....superbly

and it made a better impression on me than... cassie

Geeg

30-10-2004

Very disappointed in Sharon's comments.

tally

30-10-2004

Originally Posted by GG:
“Steve - Oh geez - last week I was saying I didnt get him, didnt like him - this week, I thought it was brilliant.”

Yeah, GG. Getting into the groove!

RPM

30-10-2004

Louis would make a good drag act

Kewpee

30-10-2004

Ew Sharon...not a good comment

Steve was good, I love his tone, the choir was unnecessary again!

metafis

30-10-2004

Oh Sharon!. well, I didnt like Steve but those comments by her were a bit off.

thms

30-10-2004

Originally Posted by Ruby_:
“Sharon waaaay overstepped the mark with that comment. "You're not black, you've got no soul." Totally out of order - and racist in my view.”

my thoughts too Ruby_
but i don't think sharon intended it to be racist

Benc533

30-10-2004

Love the Voices With Soul Part Political Broadcast

flicker

30-10-2004

Yes, for once I disagree with Sharon, contradicting herself by saying he is the British Michael Bolton - well he is white.

*buttercup*

30-10-2004

a lot of singers sound black,why is that a bad thing ,sharon is a racist.

tally

30-10-2004

Ugh VWS, begging never works! Such a bad move.

lorne.t

30-10-2004

Voices with soul - "Maybe people thought we were safe"!!

Benc533

30-10-2004

Originally Posted by thms:
“my thoughts too Ruby_
but i don't think sharon intended it to be racist”

I agree, I don't think it was intended to be racist at all.

thms

30-10-2004

lol simon provided all his 'acts' with a backing choir

Sara & Emma

30-10-2004

The one on the left looks like a black Big Mo Slater.

They sound excellent though.

Sara.

RPM

30-10-2004

Originally Posted by Ruby_:
“Sharon waaaay overstepped the mark with that comment. "You're not black, you've got no soul." Totally out of order - and racist in my view.”

And here was me thinking that Mary Whitehouse was dead. :yawn:

11 of 24