I was really dissapointed 2nite at the way the judge acted tonite, again. Yet tonite, unlike last week, it was louis who was mostly to blame. He just seemed to never shut his mouth! every time someone was speaking, he had to butt in an have a go. Doesnt he realise that maybe his groups would like to speak up for themselves?!
judges arguing got in the way, AGAIN!!
1 of 2
And what about Sharon I really love her but she is fast going down hill
her comments to Steve were way out of line
her comments to Steve were way out of line
Judges are spoiling it for me. Next week I will mute the sound when the contestants are not singing.
Louis is seriously getting on my nerves and spoiling the show. he says nothing constructive, just makes snide little comments about Simon and his acts.
What a pathetic, spiteful, sad, sad little man he is. Just grow up ffs.
What a pathetic, spiteful, sad, sad little man he is. Just grow up ffs.
I agree. I really don't mind judges saying what they feel - but Louis just seems to use any opportunity to "have a go" - eg he praises Rowetta - then in the next breath when introducing his act says that his act doesn't need gimmicks to stay in.
Oh please - it just makes him look stupid - notice tonight he got a huge boo. If I was one of his acts I'd be saying to him - you are losing it for me - shut your gob.
Oh please - it just makes him look stupid - notice tonight he got a huge boo. If I was one of his acts I'd be saying to him - you are losing it for me - shut your gob.
I don't see why everyone has such a problem with Louis' comments. 
I agreed with everything he said.
He's my favourite part of the show!
I was sad when he got booed though, I wish I'd been in the audience to cheer him!
I agreed with everything he said.He's my favourite part of the show!
I was sad when he got booed though, I wish I'd been in the audience to cheer him!
Originally Posted by Louis_Fan:
“I thought Louis was great tonight, his comments were all very fair.
”
“I thought Louis was great tonight, his comments were all very fair.
”
ye realy fair having a pop at simon over the choir,did he not see tabby had a choir and little kids,does he only see what he wants,tabby was cheesy.fair my a*s,the most bias man ever.
I thought Louis was toady....toady and toody! 
Didn't agree with him having a pop at Simon for the choir - Steve was great and he totally ignored the fact that he sang the song brilliantly and proceeded to have a go at Simon for using the choir!
Didn't agree with him having a pop at Simon for the choir - Steve was great and he totally ignored the fact that he sang the song brilliantly and proceeded to have a go at Simon for using the choir!
Originally Posted by moneybags:
“ye realy fair having a pop at simon over the choir,did he not see tabby had a choir and little kids,does he only see what he wants,tabby was cheesy.fair my a*s,the most bias man ever.”
“ye realy fair having a pop at simon over the choir,did he not see tabby had a choir and little kids,does he only see what he wants,tabby was cheesy.fair my a*s,the most bias man ever.
”
But Tabby's backing didn't drown him out in the way the choir did Simon's acts. Steve's performance tonight would not have seemed so good if he hadn't had the choir to fall back on. And personally I think the choir ruined Rowetta's performance, she didn't need them there and would have been so much better without them.
Originally Posted by Louis_Fan:
“I don't see why everyone has such a problem with Louis' comments. I agreed with everything he said.
He's my favourite part of the show! I was sad when he got booed though, I wish I'd been in the audience to cheer him!”
“I don't see why everyone has such a problem with Louis' comments.
I agreed with everything he said.He's my favourite part of the show!
I was sad when he got booed though, I wish I'd been in the audience to cheer him!”
How can u say u agree with everything he said? he contradicted himself all the way thru the show! he loved rowetta, then made comments about the choir. all he did was try to find a way to put simon down! this isnt the louis get at simon show, an he needs to realise that.
Originally Posted by shell1981:
“How can u say u agree with everything he said? he contradicted himself all the way thru the show! he loved rowetta, then made comments about the choir. all he did was try to find a way to put simon down! this isnt the louis get at simon show, an he needs to realise that.”
“How can u say u agree with everything he said? he contradicted himself all the way thru the show! he loved rowetta, then made comments about the choir. all he did was try to find a way to put simon down! this isnt the louis get at simon show, an he needs to realise that.
”
well it all made sense to me. He loved Rowetta but not because of the choir being there. And the fact that he was so complimentary about her shows that he wasn't just out to get at Simon.
Originally Posted by Louis_Fan:
“But Tabby's backing didn't drown him out in the way the choir did Simon's acts. Steve's performance tonight would not have seemed so good if he hadn't had the choir to fall back on. And personally I think the choir ruined Rowetta's performance, she didn't need them there and would have been so much better without them.”
“But Tabby's backing didn't drown him out in the way the choir did Simon's acts. Steve's performance tonight would not have seemed so good if he hadn't had the choir to fall back on. And personally I think the choir ruined Rowetta's performance, she didn't need them there and would have been so much better without them.”
he was going on about gimicks so tabby wasnt a gimick
he never said any thing cos tabby is irish he is so bias.
Originally Posted by Louis_Fan:
“well it all made sense to me. He loved Rowetta but not because of the choir being there. And the fact that he was so complimentary about her shows that he wasn't just out to get at Simon.”
“well it all made sense to me. He loved Rowetta but not because of the choir being there. And the fact that he was so complimentary about her shows that he wasn't just out to get at Simon.”
are you irish by any chance.???
Originally Posted by Louis_Fan:
“no I'm English”
“no I'm English
”
well your wrong about louie,put it this way if you was on x factor and an irish singer even if you where a better singer he would put the irish singer through before you every time.
Originally Posted by moneybags:
“well your wrong about louie,put it this way if you was on x factor and an irish singer even if you where a better singer he would put the irish singer through before you every time.”
“well your wrong about louie,put it this way if you was on x factor and an irish singer even if you where a better singer he would put the irish singer through before you every time.
”
lol well I wouldn't be a better singer than anyone because I can't sing to save my life!
Well maybe you're right, he might put them through even if I was better. I remember the week they did the auditions in Ireland and they showed the clips of him saying yes to all those rubbish singers, made me laugh so much!
I just really like him, biased or unbiased!
I think I'll have to agree to disagree with you all when it comes to discussions about him. 
have u 2 stopped ur irish debate yet? lol. its funny to read but this thread is about the judges arguing, not whos irish or not!
Louis should go and pick his nose because he certainly can't pick songs. All his acts were at their least potential because his choice of songs were totally wrong for them. The guy thinks he knows it all, he's a total prat.
Originally Posted by shell1981:
“have u 2 stopped ur irish debate yet? lol. its funny to read but this thread is about the judges arguing, not whos irish or not!”
“have u 2 stopped ur irish debate yet? lol. its funny to read but this thread is about the judges arguing, not whos irish or not!
”
lol sorry, didn't mean to get so off-topic!
Originally Posted by shell1981:
“have u 2 stopped ur irish debate yet? lol. its funny to read but this thread is about the judges arguing, not whos irish or not!”
“have u 2 stopped ur irish debate yet? lol. its funny to read but this thread is about the judges arguing, not whos irish or not!
”
yes and louie is bias.he admits it.
The judges' sniping is distracting and irritating. It's not about them, no matter how much they might want it to be.
1 of 2
