• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • The X Factor
Poll: In your opinion, did Sharon make the right choice?
<<
<
2 of 3
>>
>
kasg
30-10-2004
Yes, no doubt from me.
thms
30-10-2004
no
VWSorCASSIE2WIN
30-10-2004
no. I think that verity shouldn't have been in the bottom two it shud hav been G4 instead of her, altho she werent far behind. Can you honestly see her winning the show? didn't think so. I couldn't help but feel sorry for her though. Two To Go dead cert for next week.
Ruby_
30-10-2004
No, it was a terrible choice. I don't like Verity's singing at all, but she's relatively inoffensive. Just think, the chance was there to switch off 2 To Go's microphones forever.
Balti
30-10-2004
Neither have the "X" factor, but glad 2 to Go were saved if just to see their "non ballad" next week.
Phil2003
30-10-2004
Absolutely yes!
kizzie
30-10-2004
well i don't like ether of them but i did think 2 to go were the ones who sang the poorest tonight

i think the judges choice makes a mockery of the public vote tho
it should be the one with the least votes goes
steg1988
30-10-2004
I really think YES she did!
BlueEyes
30-10-2004
Of course she did!
cute chick
30-10-2004
NO!

It was so predictable that she would keep 2 To Go in. She and Louis have sided against Simon.
Kristen#1
30-10-2004
Yes! Verity was dire last week and although she was better this week, she's just not in the same league as everybody else

KRISTEN
Minx Guided
31-10-2004
No! Verity pulled up her socks in comparison to last week, isn't that what you're supposed to do, improve? She improved and 2 To Go got worse. Why pick who are going backwards. Both got two chances to perform tonight and both times Verity performed better.

Neither are in with a chance to win however give the better performer of the night credit for what they did by giving them a chance in the next round. Verity was the better performer tonight.
Mykonos
31-10-2004
Originally Posted by Minx Guided:
“ Verity was the better performer tonight.”

Couldn't argue with that but I did wonder if Sharon looked at the bigger picture before voting.Verity was really poor last week and should really have gone before Roberta but didn't.Perhaps that helped to influence her vote.
Deerd
31-10-2004
No she didn't and for the wrong reason (as has been mentioned above by others).

Verity and 2 to Go were the correct bottom two, imo...but Sharon, having given much support and confidence-building-comments to Verity throughout [WHILE EXPRESSING DOUBT OVER THE STRENGTH OF 2 TO GO (espesh the nasal-lassie)], ought to have voted with her inclinations towards potential -even if that potnetial was for 1 more week, merely; Verity!

Sharon voted tactically to hurt Simon and even some scores.

Sharon showed a disappointing lack of integrity tonight and highlighted the partisan flaw in the 'judges' vote system.
Dan Vincent
31-10-2004
I believe Sharon made the right decision. I thought Verity was awful. 2 to Go weren't great, but they weren't anything like as bad as Verity.

Especially if you take into consideration how they were playing the piano and also did the choreography of stage positioning etc (getting close to him at the end) it's clear that 2 to Go had the better act.
gerry d
31-10-2004
Originally Posted by Dan Vincent:
“I believe Sharon made the right decision. I thought Verity was awful. 2 to Go weren't great, but they weren't anything like as bad as Verity.

Especially if you take into consideration how they were playing the piano and also did the choreography of stage positioning etc (getting close to him at the end) it's clear that 2 to Go had the better act.”

The act that 2 To Go did is exactly right what Simon said it is one of these acts you would find in a Hotel performing on a Saturday & Sunday night in the lounge/bar section.

So they had a prop on stage(the piano) & she sat next to him.At the end of the day what goes with a good act is having a good voice & this is something that they lack in.
Bossyboots
31-10-2004
Originally Posted by lulu g:
“No, she made the wrong decision and, more importantly, she made her decision for the wrong reason.”

I agree with you here. As soon as it was announced who the bottom two were it was obvious Verity was going to go.
I_love_this
31-10-2004
I did not like any of the bottom 2 !
R-H17
31-10-2004
Absolutely not. Sharon has only shown her incompetence as a fair judge.
dudeuk87
31-10-2004
Based on last nights performance no, but based on everything they have done so far, then yes.
Spellbound
31-10-2004
Probably if it had been my choice, I would have sent 2 to Go home. Verity had raised her game this week, To to Go I felt had fallen down a bit.

In all honesty I think both acts were the weakest of the night and, if they don't raise their game next week, 2 to Go will probably go.
whip
31-10-2004
I think 2 to go were at the top of there game, unfortunatly that isn't a compliment.
beathogs
31-10-2004
I actually thought Verity was better than 2 to go last night so Sharon had a difficult decision to make ..... I do think that she has made the right decision though and look forward to seeing 2 to go doing something a bit more modern
beckymover
31-10-2004
Sharon claimed to make her decision based on who would sell more records, yet she still let 2ToGo. Admittedly, Verity would have sold records 50% on her personality and 50% on talent, but I just don't think 2ToGo have enough of the latter to compensate for the lack of the former.
CarrieSpike
31-10-2004
No, wrong choice and for the wrong reasons.. I think she just wanted to take one of Simon's toys off him.
<<
<
2 of 3
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map