Louie or Jason on ice - you choose

i am sorry Jason,
with you i never did warm,
unlike Louie,
who has gone down a storm.
you both are the same,
i do not need to mention one thing that is your similarity,
but Jason is rude, arrogant, stubborn and pig headed,
and Louie equals a perfect gent with generous charity.
are we missing Jason,
has the ice got a gap,
Louie may not have allot of hair,
but at least he is not a head slap.
i do admit about viewing,
the figures are down and that's proof,
but its a very wide market,
Jason and his teeth are a comical spoof.
i am not depressed,
dancing on ice is pure entertainment,
i no longer argue with the tv,
and my family don't need to hold me back with reattainment.
well done Louie,
you are perfect to judge,
with expertise in dancing,
you stay on that panel mate, and don't budge.


(am i in the minority when i say i like dancing on ice better now jason has gone ?)

Louis all the way too!!

I love Louie's enthusiastic positive comments and often agree with him. He has pulled the show back from the rather unpleasant undertones of previous series.

Louie by a mile!

He has more talent in his little finger than Jason has in in whole body, and can keep the crticism professional and constructive and doesn't need to resort to nasty put downs.

Sod off back to the ooze you crawled out of Jason - you had a massive opportunity - and blew it!

Louie by a country mile and then some.

Hopefully Jason's demise will signal the end of the judge who is mostly there on his own ego trip and whose personal criticisms have nothing whatsoever to do with the progress [or lack of progress] of a contestant. It's just great to watch Louie each week showing how it should be done.

Jason for me, can't stand Louie. He was spitting all over Christine's dress last night while babbling on, yuk.

Neither

Jason is a vile human being and Louie speaks so fast that you need to rewind or put subtitles on to unerstand what he says. Also, I'm sick of seeing him spitting all over the desk/Christine/Robin

Louie. The only time I missed Jason was after Chemmy performed in the first show. After all the positive comments she received it suddenly dawned on me that Jason would have hated her cuz he seemed to always have an issue with athletic built women. Then I realised the show was so much better without his snide remarks.

Louie all the way. The show is so much more enjoyable with the nastiness.

Louie every time. I couldn't stand Jason. His comments were vile.

I prefer Jason over Louie. Thankfully Louie isn't as over the top and irritating as I had feared he would be, but I'm still no fan of his. However he is bearable

I don't like either of them but Jason was the more tolerable of the two (well tolerable to a point).

Louie, Louie, Louie!

Louie by far. He makes me laugh, he's enthusiastic and constructive in his criticism. In fact I'm loving this new panel, I've never seen Robin look so relaxed and laugh as much as he has done this series.

He can't really help the way he talks though can he?

I voted for Louie... I like both but I didn't like the way that Jason's comments often seemed to overshadow the actual skating, and all the hysetrical booing.

I like Louis far more than I ever thought I would.

louis, is by far the better judge, Jason was just damn right rude to contestants, yeah i know he was playing the villian but there was no need what so ever to get personal with anybody.

Louis is miles better.

I love the judging panel this year, they've got it right for me.

For he (Louie) is a jolly good fellow, and so say all of us! Almost everything he says makes me laugh. When Jason was on, I kept wanting to take a shower.

Along with Katarina, Louie makes up the best judging panel ever on this (or any other) show,

I much prefer the current judging panel, and don't necessarily think you actually need a "baddie" to boo and hiss at.

I often felt quite uncomfortable watching when Jason was on DOI making some of his vile comments, but now I feel I can relax and enjoy the show more.

I wasn't a fan of Louie in the first couple of weeks, but he's grown on me.

I was really happy when I found out that Jason had left the show. I couldn't stand him and the way he seemed to enjoy being nasty. He was more personal than constructive, he would often comment on things that had nothing to do with the celebrities and their performances, he made it too obvious who his favourites were and who he hated.

I think Louie has been a great addition. His OTT campness annoyed me beforehand, but I've changed my opinion since he appeared on the show. He's constructive, enthusiastic and he's quite funny. He also never makes any rude or nasty comments.

Louis..knew nothing about him before DOI but no contest. He can be critical without being nasty, and humorous, something Jason was incapable of. Even if skating isn't much cop I can still watch with pleasure aside from the frigging breaks. And Bleakley.

Now if only we could get a proper judging panel on SCD.

I like Louie, he comments on what he knows - dance and performance - and doesn't pretend to know anything about actual skating.

As for his "spitting all over the desk" - he has a speech impediment, it's something he can't help. Think it's quite brave of him to go on a show where he has to talk to camera so much

so from all this - i now prenounce loui the winner - unlicky jason - hair today and gone tomoz lol

I must admit that I expected Louis to be a bit of a joke before the series began, but I was wrong. His comments are knowledgeable and positive. He points out a skater's weaknesses, but also makes suggestions on how to overcome them. He has never resorted to the nastiness that was Jason's trademark, which only goes to show that there is no need for it.