Originally Posted by j4Rose:
“The whole thing feels rigged to an extent. I doubt Maria will win, but she wouldn't even have made it this far with anyone else. It annoyed me that she received the first perfect score. Katherine still hasn't had one perfect score yet.
I remember Carrie Ann saying that she thinks everyone is capable of getting a ten. The ten of one celeb may not be equal to that of another celeb, but she thinks that everyone is capable of a ten. What utter unfair BS! I do think they hold certain people to a higher standard.”
BIB - I'm sure they do and to an extent, I think it's fair enough. Some celebs come to this better equipped than others. I don't mean Katherine's a ringer, or anything, but she's a performer, musically aware etc and she's done a bit of stage dancing before. In the first few weeks, I think that probably helped her, so I don't have a problem with them being a bit 'encouraging' with celebs who make good progress early on (as Maria did from week one to week two). By this stage though, I think things have evened out and as we get to the nitty gritty, I think the judges should be even-handed and sticklers for the rules.
It's fine saying Maria's samba was fun or entertaining or really well danced (all true), but it rankles with me that only Len held them to account for not dancing a samba!
I think this thread is in danger of sounding very anti-Maria, but it's tricky - when the judges let so much go 'uncritiqued' and the show seems biased towards Derek - not to feel a bit grumpy about it

.
For what it's worth, I'd be happy to see Maria in the final. She and Derek entertain me more than William and Cheryl. She's made massive improvements and seems like a fun (and gorgeous) girl, but they need to lay off the showmance angle, keep schtum about their ailments and dance the dance they're meant to be doing.
(Oh, and a perception of bias isn't helped by having them dance last both times

)