Is Matt being unfairly favoured?

3 of 3

Petite Fleur

12-03-2012

Originally Posted by yellowlabbie:
“His performance was not worth a 9.5, it's ludicrous. It's nothing to do with being a Jorgie fan, it's about fairness and there has been none tonight. Chico, Chemmy, Matt and Jen all overmarked, and poor Jorgie grossly undermarked. The show is now a joke. The judges should hang their heads in shame.”

So they were all overmarked except poor little Jorgie.

Guess the only time the judges are fair is when she tops the leaderboard.

looby383x

12-03-2012

Originally Posted by norbitonite:
“But he's not competing against Ray or Chris. Whilst I agree that there have been weeks when Jorgie has outperformed him, she has usually outscored him in those weeks. Likewise, when Chico surpassed him, he also outranked him on the leaderboard. Neither's performance was better than his tonight.

Jorgie's marks from Robin and Kati were not ungenerous, it's only Louie who gave her a surprisingly low score.”

I agree, although I'm not convinced that Louie's score was undeserved.

Not because she didn't perform her routine well, because she did. But she can't be scored on what the judges believe her to be capable of - they can only score her on the level of skating she actually performed. She was not served well by her choreography and T & D have a lot to answer for.

For me, the only thing that was wrong with the relative scores is that Jen should have been bottom, and Jorgie next to bottom. I'm glad Jorgie stayed as she is capable of so much more that we saw on Sunday.

NorthernNinny

12-03-2012

Originally Posted by happy tv:
“I thought the same with Strictly. I noticed that the BBC employees were always over marked. However, Andy got a hard time and he is also employed by ITV”

They can't work miracles however. Andy was rubbish.

footygirl

12-03-2012

Originally Posted by looby383x:
“I agree, although I'm not convinced that Louie's score was undeserved.

Not because she didn't perform her routine well, because she did. But she can't be scored on what the judges believe her to be capable of - they can only score her on the level of skating she actually performed. She was not served well by her choreography and T & D have a lot to answer for.

For me, the only thing that was wrong with the relative scores is that Jen should have been bottom, and Jorgie next to bottom. I'm glad Jorgie stayed as she is capable of so much more that we saw on Sunday.”

Yeah I don't think Tand D really do their utmost with the celebs - look at how rubbish their routines for Charlene were, they just didn't put any real thought into it for me.

It happened last year - Laura is bottom 2- following week she gets the flashy programme. I wish they would pull their plugs out for Chico

Katenutzs

12-03-2012

No I dont think he is being favoured,

3 of 3