Louis has given Andy a 7.5 on some occasions.

Can anyone really say that any of Andys routines deserved more then the one Jorgie just did?

I understand if people think she deserved a lower mark, but a 6.5 just seems ridiculous to me..

He was showing off simple as.

I think the mark was a bit low, but the performance wasn't amazing. 8.5 would of been far more accurate

Ridiculous, ridiculolus, ridiculous.

I thought she deserved overall a 25. So no.

Fair mark I thought. And ALL the judges agreed that she should be lower than Chico and Chemmy, so I think it's a fair result.

I also reckon Robins first score was what he meant but got such a look from Chris that he suddenly asked to change it, least Louis had the guts to stick with his score

Louis could get in alot of hot water with Christopher Dean over this. 8.5 would've been fine but a 6'5 was an insult to him even though the cherography was bad.

But each week they have been given marks based on the number of weeks that have gone by. The marks that they all got in week one they wouldnt be given now if they did the same standard of a routine.

I dont think she deserved any more. Maybe sllightly highter from Louie but the others were too high so it evened itself out.

no she didnt

I think it was right there was no real performance there for me it was flat and Jorgies expression was pretty much the same throughout the entire routine and think like others Robin did mean that score as she was doing just basic skating but felt he had to up it.

No she didn't. Louie's mark was absurd. And done for effect because the show was in need of some controversy.

But for weeks now, Jorgie's been scoring higher than Chemmy & Chico (and soemtimes Matt) with the other two judges despite her skating not being as strong. Tonight was the first time I thought Robin & Katarina marked her properly in relation to the others.

I think the problem I had was that Jorgie only had the one prop! It might have been the "most difficult" but, the perception was she only had to concentrate on mastering the one item, and because of that I think Louie's mark was a fair one. I might have gone to 7 but, considering that the others had to worry about making sure 4 or 5 other items had to go right on the night I wouldn't have given her any more than that.

6.5 yes.

She skated on her own, yes. However, if you watch it back, her skating is not complex AT ALL! She basically skated in a line, picked up speed, and glided along the ice.

I love Jorgie btw, and want her to win, but she was the worst technical skater tonight. Sadly.
I have voted six times and hopefully *crosses fingers* she is saved!

I agree

It was a bit of a low mark (7.5 or 8 would have been more appropriate) but I did find it performance wise the worst of the evening .. dull compared to the others and not very challenging skating wise (with the exception of Jen who's routine was dreadful from a skating point of view as it contained hardly any)

Same

Same, i think he though "Oh, i gave a 5.5 and Katriana gave 8.5" so had to change it!

I did say the same as Louis that it was a boring routine. He took it too far with a 6.5 though. I think I would of scored it 7.5 or 8.

Since the blade in the head incident she has gone backwards and it seems to me that her professional partner is holding her back.

Didn't like the routine much - the others had much harder props. Agree with Louie - boring

BIB I think you might have a point there. It was quite telling after the accident Matt said something along the lines that the accident should make Jorgie listen more or wtte.

I'm sorry....but I thought it was absolutely gorgeous and amazing and my favorite routine of the night by a mile.

The score was absolutely ridiculous....period!

I think Louie's mark was accurate and that Robin bottled it, we've seen mistakes before and both Louie and Robbin had a look in their eyes, like a deer staring into headlights. Never seen that look before and it was really stark.

Like "oh shit we're in for a hard time"

Jorgie is by far my favourite, followed pretty much equally by Matt and Chemmy. She is capable of so much but that performance showed none of it.

It ws graceful and elegant but there was no actual content, no dance at all that I can recall, just skating around in a circle with a few real basic lifts.

It was her worst performance and the worst of tonight, for her to be so boring that Jen surpasses her Chris and Jayne has ****ed up epically and Chris needs to get over himself, his reaction was because someone dared to criticise his choreography, not because a masterpiece was shot down.

I agree, his eyes said it all, scardy cat

I found the routien so boring, and no ooomph