• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • TV Shows: Reality
  • Past Reality Shows
  • Dancing On Ice: All Stars
Come On Jen
<<
<
4 of 5
>>
>
Tejas
18-03-2012
Originally Posted by footygirl:
“sorry - talking at cross purposes- I do think Jennifer should go though as she is not as good as skater as the other three. For me Matt and Chico are the best two skaters, either one would deserve to go straight through to the final

Jorgie and Jennifer - well Jorgie is better than Jennifer but the problem is the Dan Whiston fanbase, that may ultimately cost Chico a place in the final”

Hopefully the judges will prevent that from happening in the skate-off though, if Chico was up against Jen its hard to imagine them saving her - although anything can happen!

I'd rate Jen lowest out of the last four, but wouldn't mind too much if she made the final over Jorgie as I've grown really tired of her lately whereas I've warmed to Jen quite a bit. The final would be much poorer without Chico in it though, IMO.
footygirl
18-03-2012
I will be voting like no ones business for Chico tonight - he really deserves to be in the final
amelie74
18-03-2012
I enjoy watching Jen's performances - she acts it out well and her lines and flexibility are impressive. However I do feel she's the weakest technical skater of the remaining 4 and probably should go tonight although I feel Chico is the most vulnerable on the viewers vote.
gazb2
18-03-2012
Originally Posted by amelie74:
“I enjoy watching Jen's performances - she acts it out well and her lines and flexibility are impressive. However I do feel she's the weakest technical skater of the remaining 4 and probably should go tonight although I feel Chico is the most vulnerable on the viewers vote.”

It'll be a Jen/Chico skate off....and I really hope Chico pulls off something amazing as he does deserve a place in the final - especiallllllly over Jen
Tiggergirl
18-03-2012
Originally Posted by gazb2:
“It'll be a Jen/Chico skate off....and I really hope Chico pulls off something amazing as he does deserve a place in the final - especiallllllly over Jen”

Yet you say you don't hate Jennifer funny way of not hating someone by keeping posting "especially against Jennifer".

I think she has improved and fully deserves to be in this competition and I truly hope she makes it to the final. If she does it will be as much on her own fanbase not that of Dan's despite some posters insistence that she is only getting votes because of him.
FoolishFearless
18-03-2012
I love watching Jen and Dan but I agree she is the worst of the 4 left. Chico and Matthew are the best skaters therefore deserve a place in the final as does Jorgie (although I personally dont think shes as good as the two guys but I do like her). But we cant say anyone is definately safe. Even if Jen is against Chico in the skate off, either of them could have a fall or a stumble or anything. Nobody is safe. If something goes wrong in the skate off then the other couple who has a better skate therefore deserves to go through.

It'll be a great final no matter who goes through however, all 4 are fantastic
SydneyHedgehog
18-03-2012
Originally Posted by Tiggergirl:
“I think she has improved and fully deserves to be in this competition and I truly hope she makes it to the final.”

You can hope shes in the final, but she doesnt deserve to be there.

Ask yourself this.

Is she better than either of the guys? Nope.

Is she better than Jorgie? Nope.

So therefore you have your answer ..........
TraceyUK
18-03-2012
Originally Posted by SydneyHedgehog:
“You can hope shes in the final, but she doesnt deserve to be there.

Ask yourself this.

Is she better than either of the guys? Nope.

Is she better than Jorgie? Nope.

So therefore you have your answer ..........”

Just because someone isnt quite as good doesnt mean they cant or wont be there.

Realistically I know she more than likely wont be there but like Tiggergirl I would love it if by any miracle she did make it to the final
SydneyHedgehog
18-03-2012
Originally Posted by TraceyUK:
“Just because someone isnt quite as good doesnt mean they cant or wont be there.

Realistically I know she more than likely wont be there but like Tiggergirl I would love it if by any miracle she did make it to the final”

Im not disagreeing with you at all, at the end of the day the 'popularity' contest still counts. But Im saying strictly in terms of skating ........ which is really what the show is about, she is the worst skater. Thats not being nasty. Its just fact.
hownwbrowncow
18-03-2012
Now Jens out I'm behind Chico. The other two do not appeal to me...
TraceyUK
18-03-2012
Gutted for Jen and Dan especially since Jorgie messed up the non headbanger again, but shes done well to get this far and have loved watching her progress week by week.
Petite Fleur
18-03-2012
My disappointment for Jen was somewhat tempered by seeing Jorgie in the skate off.
JohnCurry
18-03-2012
I didn't expect her to be in the final, but I am glad she made it to the semi. She has been the most outstanding personality this year, and I hope she stays with her skating and works hard for a few years, combining skating with ballet.

Incidentally, when people say that her performing is better than her skating, they said the same thing about John Curry at the beginning of his career. Then he buckled down and worked hard, and became our greatest male Olympic gold medallist.
SULLA
18-03-2012
She knew she would be going out and was totally realistic and gracious.

a good skater but just not in the top 3.
SydneyHedgehog
18-03-2012
Originally Posted by TraceyUK:
“Gutted for Jen and Dan especially since Jorgie messed up the non headbanger again, but shes done well to get this far and have loved watching her progress week by week.”

Jen wouldnt have been able to do the headbanger a year from now ........ thats the difference.
TraceyUK
18-03-2012
Originally Posted by SydneyHedgehog:
“Jen wouldnt have been able to do the headbanger a year from now ........ thats the difference.”

only because she is too tall
SydneyHedgehog
18-03-2012
Originally Posted by TraceyUK:
“only because she is too tall”

5'6 is too tall?????
TraceyUK
18-03-2012
Originally Posted by SydneyHedgehog:
“5'6 is too tall?????”

when your partnered with someone whos 5'11 then yes it is.
SydneyHedgehog
18-03-2012
Originally Posted by TraceyUK:
“when your partnered with someone whos 5'11 then yes it is.”

what does the difference need to be?

5'11 is the average height of a bloke.
petertard
18-03-2012
Chris Dean is 5' 11''; Jayne Torvill is 5' 3'', and 8'' difference. Is that the ideal height differential ? If so, Jen needs someone 6' 2''.
Malbren
18-03-2012
Jen had come on leaps and bounds but it was right that she went tonight, she was 4th best of the 4, so right outcome. She did well to make the semi's and went out on a good skate off.
Snow_Leopard
18-03-2012
Originally Posted by TraceyUK:
“Gutted for Jen and Dan especially since Jorgie messed up the non headbanger again, but shes done well to get this far and have loved watching her progress week by week.”

Jorgie didn't mess it up! Looked great to me, as did the whole routine.
frally
19-03-2012
Originally Posted by SULLA:
“She knew she would be going out and was totally realistic and gracious.

a good skater but just not in the top 3.”

If she was truly realistic and gracious, she wouldn't have begged the GBP to vote for her by promising to be "brilliant" in the final, as the top 3 are way out of her league, as shown in the big gap of 7-8.5 points.
Instead, she should have done as Audley Harrison did in SCD, which was offer to step aside rather than deprive any of the other three far superior skaters of a place in the final.
Thankfully the GBP had more sense and didn't save her from the skate-off.
SULLA
19-03-2012
Originally Posted by frally:
“If she was truly realistic and gracious, she wouldn't have begged the GBP to vote for her by promising to be "brilliant" in the final, as the top 3 are way out of her league, as shown in the big gap of 7-8.5 points.
Instead, she should have done as Audley Harrison did in SCD, which was offer to step aside rather than deprive any of the other three far superior skaters of a place in the final.
Thankfully the GBP had more sense and didn't save her from the skate-off.”

She was entitled to ask for votes. However when she was in the bottom 2 that she when she knew the game was up.
Tiggergirl
19-03-2012
Originally Posted by frally:
“If she was truly realistic and gracious, she wouldn't have begged the GBP to vote for her by promising to be "brilliant" in the final, as the top 3 are way out of her league, as shown in the big gap of 7-8.5 points.
Instead, she should have done as Audley Harrison did in SCD, which was offer to step aside rather than deprive any of the other three far superior skaters of a place in the final.
Thankfully the GBP had more sense and didn't save her from the skate-off.”

Why should she have stepped aside she had every right to still be in the show and had she made the final then she had every right to be there if the public wanted her there. You are told vote for your favourite not vote for the absolute best skater in the show and personally I am fed up of there being perfect stars in the show like there has been since Ray and preferred the earlier years when at least everyone started out on a more level field and progressed.

Personally I also find it has taken away from the show that ultimately the judges have chosen two of the final three again I think given it is meant to be down to a public vote then surely the public should be left to pick their finalists regardless of what production and T&D want.

Also agree Jorgies headbanger was not IMO even a headbanger and I don't think it went right on either occasion.
<<
<
4 of 5
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map