No surprise. She has found her level.

Loved her!! I think she will have the right balance of warmth and steel as the show progresses. She looked genuinely moved by Jonathan & Charlotte, Sam Kelly and The Sugar Dandies but also showed a feisty side with those girls who were 'freestyle dancing'. Unlike Cheryl Cole who disapppointed me as I thought she would show some of her fiesty side on the X Factor but we hardly saw any of it!!

She was awful on Strictly and I'm so pleased she has left that programme. Little experience and nothing worth listening to.

She wasn't awful. Just showed that she wasn't on par with the other judges. But she progressed as the show went on. But i loved her on BGT!

She had enough to win the series that year. It showed that she knew more about ballroom dancing than the three stage dancing judges, who had never been near a ballroom before they got that job.

I thought she fitted in well. I respect her judgement of general talent shows more than I do her judgement of ballroom dancing. To be honest, if her presence on BGT means she won't be seen again on SCD, that is reason enough to have her there!

I though Alesha was great! Her personality seems genuine and her laugh is hallrious. A great 4th judge imo!

After her stint on SCD the only was up

BGT is obviously more of her thing. Commenting on light entertainment doesnt require much.

I thought she was decent but don't see much of a personality in her =O

She was very nice, laughing a lot but wasn't afraid to voice her opinion. I think she's a great addition to the panel, Amanda wasn't in it a lot, even before she was missing.