Carlisle156
Your team have nothing but praise for you as a Project Manager, however I admit that I was less impressed. You weren't bad, but I think a few very crucial points missed you (your retail price, how the pitches were to be written and how the winner was actually being decided) and I think without Gav, overall, the task wouldn't have been the success it was. That said, I do think you were very good when it came to listening to your team and managing the subteams etc and, of course, the winning idea was yours.
Gav
You did a fantastic job with the costings, although there were a few mistakes with the margins. However, on the creative front you were pretty poor, which I think you yourself are aware of. Despite this, if you hadn't put in the adequate research to find the cheapest materials to produce your product, your team probably would have lost.
Jess
You were decent on this task, Jess! I would say, however, that going to Kevin after Harry had finished pitching was quite devious and that kind of underhand behaviour is unacceptable.
Amroussi
I know you were absent for much of the task, but as I said earlier, I feel like there was a lack of flexibility when it came to organising a pitch for you. I actually think it was borderline stitching you up. Afterall, you wouldn't have had anything to show for the task in the boardroom.
Val
You did make some decent contributions to the brainstorming and you are 50% of the reason you got the order that swung it for you. However, apart from these things, I didn't see all that much from you.