Originally Posted by Kingsy:
“Have to agree with the "every song sounds the same". After a few tracks in I could imagine exactly what the next one would sound like.
The only song that's unique is the last one, the ballad.
(I like Let it Go though.)”
People need to make up their minds. With "Overcome", you had people moaning that every song sounds different, like they were just there to fill every niche. Supposedly, Alex was just a "pop puppet" with no distinctive sound of her own. Now she's gone out and executive produced an album that is designed to have one overarching "sound", people still complain.
Better for Alex to do this and show growth and maturity as an artist, than do the same crap Pixie Lott did for her second album (that she did for her first), which was toss out a collection of unrelated songs that sounded completely different, but could appeal to different markets as singles.
People don't actually know what albums are supposed to sound like anymore, because of this approach.
Cohesive albums often have songs that share a similarity of sound across the whole album. The Beach Boys "Pet Sounds" is considered a pop masterpiece. If you listened to preview snippets of Pet Sounds, it'd be pretty easy to conclude that "the songs sound the same", because their is a cohesiveness in style, genre and production designed to make a tight record.
Not calling Heartbreak On Hold the new Pet Sounds or anything, but's it's damned refreshing to see a British pop artist actually try to do something this cohesive.