Elise...and don't know why Jimmy doesn't like her...


She performs well with lots of emotion and isn't body stiff like some are. Don't like that song, but she did well with it all the same

8/10

Hey DS, I did edit the title to 7pm-9pm, but it doesn't show up for me...just thought to mention that.

Could be Elise is nervous and why she giggled re her sick dog....being on telly and all that, fingering her hair too.

ads

That was one of Elise's better ones, but (quite understandably) she's always singing like it's such an arduous, miserable task.

Aww poor dog.

I thought hollie did well, starting the show is hard let alone acapella.

I thought elise sounded a bit rough but I think that's just her type of voice.

but, i love my dogs and i love people who also love their dogs! aw poor elise.

I only saw half of colton as i was putting the spuds on lol.

i hate that bloody lady gaga song. he's not really my cup of tea but he should be safe, he deserves to be.

i actually find elise quite awkward to look at - yes she moves about but i find it really forced like she isn't comfortable doing it.

i assumed she giggled because people who don't own dogs would probably think it was a crappy excuse and she probably realised that and was a bit embarassed about saying it - although people with dogs will know how horrible it feels when your dog is ill and you aren't there for them

Back to the pawn shop worker, so says Ryan anyway.

Phillip.....Jimmy impressed with a new voice, could pick up some new fans..

To me he sounds the same...doesn't rivet me...sort of ok

7/10

I bloody love the blonde saxophonist.

Although I get a bit distracted from the singing watching her molest that instrument!

Not bad from P-Squared at all.

If I have a least favourite then it's possibly Phillip. His voice sounds like a chainsaw.

Hmm not bad though.
Am usually waiting for him to explode. I mean the dude seriously overheats.

Very true what you say, even people with cats would feel same for them. We had to put our cat down years ago, and you always remember, how you tried to save cat against the odds.

Woah great song choice for Jessica.

Hope she does well. She'll be singing for her life. Idol isn't a girls world anymore.

Jessica....Jimmy, she has to blow the mind tonight...

Looks well in that get-up....don't know about blowing the mind, but she's doing well with that song. full of emotion but is it enough..don't know

8/10

Country twist on Gaga...and something else Ryan rattled off...

ads

Yes, but did she blow you away with her performance? She didn't for me, so I wondered...

Blew me away is a bit strong. Though I'd say she's technically the best singer on the show.

Hmm good choice by Skylar. Very interesting so far. Love the violin. lol

2 songs each tonight...


Skylar....Jimmy loved Born This way...so do I, and I got to hearing it before it was in the shops too, then heard her whole album....yay!

Country meets Gaga.....don't know if Skylar's style is that special. Skylar makes it sound like rock....that last note seemed out of place...

8/10 for trying

Slightly rough start from Skylar but she picked it up and delivered it with her usual punch

Here comes Joshua

Probably my least favourite left in the competition!

Naturally technical....but is it enough, am really unsure.


Joshua....woo that jacket is hot red! He has come on over the weeks, and only singer tonight to give me goosebumps....10/10

Joshua can SING!

Not quite as good as Fantasia's version, but still best so far tonight.

Hollie and a message from Liverpool FC on screen...can you translate that says Ryan.


Soul train....must see TV show of its time....and Big Hair.

Hollie and Son of a Preacher Man....em, don't think this suits her, went through it too fast...

7/10

1978 for Colton on piano


Don't think much of this either....7/10

Glad the judges agree with me...10/10 for them.