Skylar, Phillip


Jimmy re ...Skylar, great 1st song, 2nd was indulgent, didn't cut the mustard, got knocked out.

Jimmy re Phillip the lady-killer( according to Ryan)....having a rough time, lacking energy, 2nd song, happy to see disagreement between judges, left an opeing for someone to be in the finale...

Skylar.....bottom 3 ( that's a surprise)
Phillip...safe

Skylar..safe....they love to kid


Elise and Hollie....
Hollie....safe


Elise leaves....shame, and good luck to Elise for the future, it ain't over yet gal. hugs

Looks like the BB electric shocker has been atttached to Jennifer

Elise rocking out. Probably the best exit song all series.

She may never have managed to shake off the bottom three, but she made top 6, no matter where she came in the voting each week that's still great.

Sorry to see Elise go, hope she does well out of the show.
Was hoping to see Philip in the bottom, but it wasn't to be, I suppose he is eye candy for the young girls.

Elise sounds good with this number, and has a lot of oomph too. lol like that close face with Steven.

Show's over, and wish it wouldn't just cut off! boo

I'm really glad Hollie is still in, I never imagined her making top 5 a couple weeks ago. Elise was great too so its a shame to see her go.

See ya all next week, but ain't gonna make a Thread that's for sure....

Have a good weekend. -waves-

I think Elise is one of those who really suffered due to the stress of the competition, especially facing the bottom three so many times.
She came across rather awkward and insecure in alot of her performances, but then as soon as she's not being judged she relaxes and has fun.

Yeah, think you're right, as she came over shy at times. Maybe she wasn't ready for this year's AI, but went for it to see how she fared, also going for it would have given her confidence to progress. That last performance was superb, and that's the sort of music she should do. I think she'll do well.

As for AI, Elise was my winner. It's a shame she didn't get the votes, but to make the Top 6 was a fantastic achievment.

And the older ones too! I find him so attractive I hardly even notice what he's singing.

Do people think he's good looking then? can't really see he's anything more than average looking but each to their own I suppose

I'm not sorry to see the back of Elise - last year I may well have supported her, but this year there are too many other good ones.

Joshua is amazing, way at the top of the pack, and I also like Philip and Skylar, and Jessica puts in some great performances too. If Hollie goes next week, I'll be a happy bunny - I have been happy with every evictee so far!

The Queen performances were not good imo - lots seemed to like Skylar, but I found her performance almost laughable - she can't keep the twang out her voice and it just did not suit a Queen song. Hollie's 'Save Me' was deathly dull, and the round, as usual, went to Joshua.

Joshua took round 2 as well, despite a fantastic performance by Jessica and good work from Phillip.

I agree. He has that certain something.

Not me particularly lol but the fact that he gets screams from the girls in the crowd and is dubbed 'lady killer', I think that's certainly a demographic he appeals to.

I'm not saying he deserves to be eliminated, but he's certainly not deserving to have escaped the bottom three all this time while everyone else has been there.

I was an Elise fan, though I agree that her song choices let her down this week. She needed a big emotional song like The Show Must Go On, or Who wants to live Forever.

I like Philip's voice but find him uncomfortable to watch - he looks really unattractive when he sings - but I really liked the second song he did. He's in the final for sure - I think Holly will be out next week.

I agree, I think Joshua is amazing, no contest as far as I'm concerned.