• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • TV Shows: Reality
  • Past Reality Shows
  • American Idol
AI..Top.5 Performances..ITV2..3/5/2012..7pm/9pm..UKPace ( No Spoilers)
<<
<
2 of 4
>>
>
Dix
03-05-2012
Really Steve didn't know that song....wow, you'd think he would know it...Jen liked it....Randy re Leona, so he knows it, and actually liked Hollie's version..surprise, surprise...
Patti-Ann
03-05-2012
Originally Posted by Dix:
“Hollie doing Bleeding Love.....when Leona sang it I got goosebumps....

Hollie's version hasn't same power as Leona had, but it's not too bad. 7.5/10”

She's brave to tackle that song as it's bound to cause comparisons
meglosmurmurs
03-05-2012
Nice spinning tie-dye background. lol

Think Phillip just followed through on that note.
Dix
03-05-2012
Back after ads...

Phillip.....Time of the Season...Jimmy's friend is funny. lol

Can't remember that song, but has a lazy, laid back feeling about it. Do feel it suits Phillip, although his top notes tend to get lost. 7/10
meglosmurmurs
03-05-2012
Yey I know this song from the end of Ghostbusters 2 when they get the Statue of Liberty walking through the streets.

All 3 girls doing well, really like the tone of Hollie's voice.
Dix
03-05-2012
Originally Posted by Patti-Ann:
“She's brave to tackle that song as it's bound to cause comparisons ”

That's the trouble with comparisons, you can't help making them. Did think it might have been too big a song for her. I like Hollie and her voice, but feel she's not letting herself go, as if she's afraid to...


Girl Trio...Higher and Higher....isn't going to stretch them...

Steve...weird arrangement. lol
Jen...felt it suited them better etc...cute little dolls
Randy...weird arrangement

ads
Dix
03-05-2012
Skylar.....You Don't Have To Say You Love Me...by Dusty Springfield. Dusty had a softer voice than Skylar. Skylar's version isn't anything special to me....7/10
Dix
03-05-2012
Jen to Skylar...you want to win don't you! Skylar laughs she does...but they all do....so why say anything!
Dix
03-05-2012
Jessica...You Are So Beautiful....Joe Cocker....

Sings it well,with some feeling and nice ending....8/10
Dix
03-05-2012
lol, at Ryan putting her heels on her feet. lol
ads
rivercity_rules
03-05-2012
Loved Hollie's Bleeding Love.

I really want her to outlast at least Joshua or Jessica just to silence the judges a little bit.
Dix
03-05-2012
Back to Joshua, Jimmy and his funny friend.

Joshua....lots of feeling at the start, and he's getting top marks from me, as he's moved me with this number.

10/10
JMTD
03-05-2012
Oh my goodnes, ANOTHER standing ovation for him, you couldn't make this up, ridiculous.

I've never rooted against somebody as much as I am this guy. I really hope he doesn't win and we get to see the look on the faces of these three, madness.

Anyway, Hollie best of the night by a distance for me.
Dix
03-05-2012
For me...

1...Joshua
2....Hollie
3....Jessica
4....Phillip
5....Skylar


see you tomorrow for the results' show....-waves- xxx
meglosmurmurs
03-05-2012
Thought Joshua went a bit overboard towards the end of it.
But, even though I think the judges love him too much, I am fond of his performances most, along with Jessica and Hollie.

Tonight my overall song ranking is:
1. Jessica, Hollie and Skylar 'Higher and Higher'
2. Jessica '1: Proud Mary'
3. Jessica '2: You Are So Beautiful'
4. Joshua '2: To Love Somebody'
5. Hollie '2: Bleeding Love'
6. Skylar '2: You Don't Have to Say You Love Me'
7. Joshua '1: Ain't Too Proud to Beg'
8. Hollie '1: River Deep - Mountain High'
9. Phillip '2: Time of the Season'
10. Phillip and Joshua 'You've Lost That Lovin' Feelin''
11. Skylar '1: Fortunate Son'
12. Phillip '1: The Letter'

I like Jessica but not usually this much.

And I just wish Phillip would leave already :yawn: he's totally stuck as the same thing every week. His voice sounds like he's gargling.

Should be an interesting results show.
OxfordGirl
03-05-2012
Originally Posted by Dix:
“Back after ads...

Phillip.....Time of the Season...Jimmy's friend is funny. lol

Can't remember that song, but has a lazy, laid back feeling about it. Do feel it suits Phillip, although his top notes tend to get lost. 7/10”

I think Blake Lewis sang this one - I preferred his version
mrs.deschanel
03-05-2012
Did Randy just say Terence Trent D'Arby was from England? Really Randy? TTD is from New York which wasn't over here last time I looked.

Phillip is my favourite of what's left but I didn't like him tonight at all. He hurt my ears. The duet with Joshua was hilariously camp and just downright ropey. Hollie I find soulless - technically proficient but a singbot. Skylar I kind of liked tonight despite my hatred of Country, Jessica is too stage school for me but another one who is technically proficient. Someone should feed her though. Joshua is pimped too much which is irritating. I think I'm just moody that there's no Elise or Colton now.
Dazzer1971
03-05-2012
Originally Posted by JMTD:
“Oh my goodnes, ANOTHER standing ovation for him, you couldn't make this up, ridiculous.

I've never rooted against somebody as much as I am this guy. I really hope he doesn't win and we get to see the look on the faces of these three, madness.

Anyway, Hollie best of the night by a distance for me.”

Your a joker lol. Joshua can sing better than Hollie in first gear. He is probably about a thousand times better then her. Surely Phillip is going after tonight - he sounded lame compared to the others.
Dazzer1971
03-05-2012
For me tonight:

Joshua. Not hit one bad note. Does everything to perfection.

Jessica. The second song was beautiful.

Hollie. Had a good night. Belts a song out but heard many like her.

Skylar. Thought she was average on both songs tonight.



Phillip. Fell asleep.
mimik1uk
03-05-2012
Originally Posted by Dazzer1971:
“For me tonight:

Joshua. Not hit one bad note. Does everything to perfection.

Jessica. The second song was beautiful.

Hollie. Had a good night. Belts a song out but heard many like her.

Skylar. Thought she was average on both songs tonight.



Phillip. Fell asleep.”


dont think anyone could fall asleep during phillips second song , he was so bad when he tried to hit the high notes it was like running fingernails down a blackboard

i really liked him at the start of the series but every song he sings just sounds the same and its boring tbh
mimik1uk
03-05-2012
really annoyed with the song choices tonight btw

we were meant to be having a 60s round and then a britpop round but most of the britpop songs were 60s songs as well which kinda spoiled it for me

i was expecting a better selection of modern british songs

hollie was only one who did something contemporary
Cstar2229
03-05-2012
Standouts

Joshua and Jessica


Good

Hollie and Skylar - bet one of these go


Go home

Phillip - but he will stay
Jaxxfan
03-05-2012
If Joshua wins this show I will give up watching it :yawn:

I'm still getting over Pia Toscano's ridiculously early exit last season

My order for this week:

1. Hollie
2. Jessica




3. Phillip
4. Skylar


5. Joshua
unclekevo
03-05-2012
Did I miss something or did Phillip sing a Cranberries song for Britpop week? The Cranberries are from the Republic Of Ireland
Carlisle156
04-05-2012
Originally Posted by unclekevo:
“Did I miss something or did Phillip sing a Cranberries song for Britpop week? The Cranberries are from the Republic Of Ireland ”

He sang a song by The Zombies - who are British?
<<
<
2 of 4
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map