hate amanda, but simon can't seem to get rid of her, god knows why

but i like alesha, david is hilarious when he annoys simon. it works well.

alesha is brilliant!

i detested her on strictly but i love her now!

david is fantastic!

even amanda im warming too and ive never liked her

david is getting to predictive. too smug... sorry he have to go..

Yes.

I was a massive fan of Alesha before she joined anyway so I think she's brilliant on there. Surprisingly, I've warmed to both David and Amanda despite not being fans of them before watching.

Personally, I wouldn't mind if it's just Alesha, David and Amanda next year. They could carry the show without Simon.

simon likes all the attention.dear...

Yeah, true. I think it says something when Simon's the weak link out of all of them (imo). He doesn't seem like he wants to be there sometimes.

correct, he wants all the money though.. more Botox. more hair dye,, middle age man.. trying to go back in years.. foolish man..

This is so true! And it really goes to show they are the best panel yet when you realise you could do without Simon and not miss him. Without him on X Factor the panel is boring, but Alesha, Amanda and David seem to have so much fun and genuinely seem to be friends too. No bitchiness between the girls and love how they all got up dancing to LMFAO haha. Did you notice how Simon doesn't sit on the judging panel for the interviews on BG More Talent? Thought that was pretty sly. Not doing his job properly now either!

Have to laugh how Simon keeps moaning about the £250k share of the prize he is contributing yet he came up with that terrible show where all someone had to do was say Red or Black and get lucky on a massive roulette wheel with a beach ball bouncing around it to take a million quid of his money

I think you mean predictable! But I don't agree with you - he has livened the panel up tremendously.

I love David and can actually watch it now because of him.

Alesha is trying to hard to be cool and relevant imo.

Alesha in my opinion is the best judge on there. David Walliams is a prize pr**k... He is milking this 'him and Simon' carry on to beyond boring.. He seems to think the show is all about his OCD with Simon Cowell..You can see Alesha and Amanda cringe when he starts his stupidity. Only my opinion, of course

David clearly is the best

That's your opinion, of course.

The only one I'm not fussed about is Amanda, she's a waste of space.
I didn't like David at first, but I like the way he rips the pee out of Mr smug Simon.

I feel the same - love David and Alesha, don't mind Amanda this series as much as I used to, and I think the three of them would be fine without Simon. The chemistry between them all is great.

If they could switch Amanda for someone else this panel would be perfect. I really think David is perfect for this show and I love Alesha.

I really like the panel. David just makes me laugh!

Although Amanda has had a lot of criticism recently (some of it from me), I am beginning to think that she does belong on the panel. She is certainly very intelligent, and is taking the part of the grounded, feet-on-the-floor judge, not being an entertaining personality but delivering some sound judgements, which I think we need on this panel. The other three can get the laughs.

And yes, I think this is undoubtedly the best panel ever, with the judges being as entertaining as the acts (sometimes more so).