Is it just me that thinks Jessica is a little off form tonight?

Some negative vibes from Randy....he didn't get it...well someone thought to make that song into a duet...hmmm

..and Rock of Ages...


a quartet now....think Hollie is strongest with this number 8/10

wasn't keen on the production of the quartet

Back....Part 2...with Jimmy


Phillip......Jimmy pleased with Volcano, is thrilled.

Certainly different style for Phillip, not bad at all...has depth...9/10

I think Philip has done so much better this week.

That was great from Philip - didn't know the song but really suited his voice!

That was rather good from Phillip as he wasn't growling.

Even though he's up against my fave 3 and I would like him to GTFO.

I LOVE Bonnie Raitt!!!!!!!

Hollie....has to get into the words, and don't over-sing...dark horse, has to be magificent.

She has come on a lot, and feeling the words with expressions too. 9/10

Steven wasn't keen
Jen felt she made the emotions come when they were needed.

I watched her face and she did show them naturally.
Randy on her case too...
Last edited by Dix : 11-05-2012 at 21:28

Liked Hollie, but not sure she has done enough to stay.

That's the word I was looking for - MATURITY - some songs just need it

With comments from the judges not surprising, and that comment from Jen was out of line, re the American angle. Hollie doeasn't have to make the Americans like her. Unworthy of Jen to even say it!

ads

That was the best performance of the night...even maybe the whole series. Loved, loved, loved it!!

Jen getting a plug for her song in part 3...


Joshua...A Man's World. (Jimmy crazy man indeed, funny with it too.)

Josh giving song a lot of welly, very high on it being a man's world...not! lol

Great performance from him though....9/10

Wow that was amazing. I just love the type of singers like Joshua who can blast a song out at you and hold nothing back.
Although the judges get a little too OTT about him and may put people off.

Hollie/Phillip/Joshua have all nailed it on at least one song tonight. Don't disappoint me Jessica.

Jess - just not my type of song

Tracks contestants wished they had written...

Jessica...Jimmy was disappointed with her last time, oh dear, if the judges saw what I saw, could be game over....

She's certainly taken hold of that song with a firm grip...quite a performance, but is it right song for her?

8/10
Last edited by Dix : 11-05-2012 at 21:56

While Jessica sang the song well, I think it's another one that is just a bit too old for her

I like philip!!!!

Me too

My ratings for this evening
1 Joshua
2 Philip ( surprisingly, as I haven't really liked him up to now)
3 Jessica
4 Hollie

Well Jessica certainly brought it in her 2nd song. Everyone nailed a performance tonight.

My ranking of every performance:
1. Joshua '2: A Man's World'
2. Phillip '2: Volcano'
3. Hollie '1: Faithfully'
4. Jessica '2: And I Am Telling You I'm Not Going'
5. Hollie '2: I Can't Make You Love Me'
6. Hollie/Jessica 'Eternal Flame'
7. Phillip '1: Have You Ever Seen The Rain?'
8. Joshua/Phillip 'This Love'
9. Joshua '1: You Raise Me Up'
10. Jessica '1: Steal Away'
11. Hollie/Jessica/Joshua/Phillip 'Waiting For A Girl Like You'

The foursome really didn't go well did it.

Oh here we go with the results. I forgot.

It did seem a bit strange to have a California theme and not do California Dreamin'.
Loved the harmonies.

Px2 called up first.

I like Philip!!

Phillip has to head back to the couch, not through yet.
Okay that was pointless.

Maybe it's to give all the stupid screamers in the audience a heartattack. In which case I support it.

Hollie up next to maybe find out her fate or to get trolled by Ryan.