Originally Posted by castalla:
“Avoid the WD TV Live like the plague - iPlayer is hopeless - cuts off the end of all programmes before they are finished.”
The BBC iPlayer app on the WD is a pass-through service which means, like Youtube's leanback app, the iPlayer app is little more than a glorified link which loads a version of iPlayer directly from the BBC.
If content is being cut off by a minute, then it's the BBC at fault not WD. Virgin Tivo users were having the exact same problem as the WD SMP and Hub use the same version of iPlayer as Tivo.
In any case the issue was fixed by the BBC nearly two months ago.
Originally Posted by castalla:
“Live streaming is impossible unless you run a dnla server on another PC and have access to various plugins.”
The clue is in the name "WD TV Live Streaming".
My SMP streams perfectly well from a NAS and the USB drive attached to the SMP streams to other devices. One of the best things about the WD TV is just how blissfully easy it is to stream content to and from any device, as long as all the devices are on the same workgroup then it's simple and rarely needs any setup.
I can send and receive files from my Windows PC and Android tablet without a problem and I can stream HD content from my WD SMP in my living room to the Samsung TV in my bedroom using Samsung's AllShare (DLNA) without any issues. All without running DLNA server on a PC and without any plug-ins.
Originally Posted by castalla:
“The user interface is clumsy and old-fashioned.”
Compared to what? It's not quite as good as the Apple TV or Boxee, but it's attractive, clean looking and simple to use. You can also customise the WD with various themes, many of which add extra features like cover flow and custom moviesheets.
In any case you can't compare the user interface of a WD TV to a Roku, the WD is a multifunction device and the Roku is a online streamer nothing more than an app based interface, though as a Roku owner I do love those banner ads on my TV

(I'm amazed more people don't complain about this).