Originally Posted by OnDatKryptonite:
“If people want high end sound there is the FLAC format which is better than CD quality. Digital earphones can produce virtually studio quality sound as the artists recorded it instead of the analogue hum or "warmth" people claim vinyl provides that robs the depth of more complex musical compositions made using digital tools and production.”
That is very true, however that benefit is only of use if the playback hardware is capable of revealing such detail. Sadly today very, very, few people, especially the young, are interested in investing in the hardware to reveal such detail. As long as it "sounds alright" they are happy.
A good quality vinyl pressing doesn't have any "analogue hum" at all and is more than capable of producing the same depth of detail as a digital recording because, as I have already said, ultimately the quality you actually hear is very much dependent upon the quality of the hardware being used.
Originally Posted by OnDatKryptonite:
“As for art work, you can zoom into megapixels if you really want to appreciate ALL the detail on the front of Dr Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band. How awful!
You seem nostalgic for a less convenient time involving the greater waste of money and resources on manufacturing unnecessary formats for a non tangible product, not thinking of all the chopped down and pulped trees and oil used to create means of conveyance for a product that does not require anything more than ears and a means of storage. I cannot figure out why except nostalgia.
I have boxes full of CDs I barely listen to because Youtube, mp3 rippers and digital files mean I don't have to use them.”
I disagree completely. For many music lovers the physical format, especially vinyl, is a very tangible product, that is why they love it so much and is one of the reasons why demand for vinyl is increasing.
I assume you are a young person. In which case you probably have never experienced what it was like as a teenager in the 1970s, as I was, when your favourite artist released a new album. That meant, after weeks of anticipation, finally making a trip in to town by bus whilst hoping the record store still had a copy, and then, after buying it, the anticipation on the way home of wondering what it will sound like before finally being able to put it on the record deck and listen to it for the first time; whilst pouring over every inch of the album artwork and the lyrics.
If you have never done that you will never understand why people hold vinyl and CD in such high regard, and for that I genuinely feel sorry for so many young people today for whom music has become a disposable commodity to be consumed and thrown away little different from fast food or anything else in today's disposable society.
I've got over 1000 albums, considerably more CDs, a "proper" Hi-fi and an MP3 player but for me an MP3 player will never replicate the pleasure of listening to a good quality vinyl pressing or a CD on my Hi-fi.