Sorry to create yetr another Rihanna thread but i have compiled a playlist of what i consider her GH should be when the time comes and have been editing and moving around songs but think its pretty much as good as its gonna get so here it is:

Pon De Replay
Umbrella
We Found Love
Only Girl (In The world)
Don't Stop The Music
Russian Roulette
Disturbia
Whats My Name ?
Rude Boy
SOS
Take A Bow
S&M
Where Have You Been
Hard
Unfaithful
Shut Up And Drive
Te Amo
Man Down
Camifornia King Bed
If Its loving That Yo Want
Talk That Talk
You Da On

So thoughts and what would yours look like ?

Sounds good to me, she should release one while she takes a break from music after TTT

Disk 1

1. Pon De Replay
2. Unfaithful
3. S.O.S
4. Umbrella (feat Jay Z)
5. Take A Bow
6. Don't Stop The Music
7. Hate That I Love You (feat Neyo)
8. Disturbia
9. Shut Up And Drive
10. Live Your Life (T.I)
11. If I Never See Your Face Again (Maroon 5)
12. Run This Town (JayZ & Kanye)
13. Russian Roulette
14. Hard
15. Rude Boy
16. Te Amo
17. Love The Way You Lie (Eminem)


Disk 2

1. Only Girl
2. What's My Name (Feat. Drake)
3. S&M
4. Cheers (Drink To That)
5. Man Down
6. We Found Love (Feat Calvin Harris)
7. You Da One
8. Talk That Talk (Feat Jay Z)
9. Where Have You Been
10. NEW SONG
11. NEW SONG
12. NEW SONG
13. Take Care (Drake)
14. Princess Of China (Coldplay)
15. S&M (Britney Remix)

Should features count as greatest hits tho?

i was thinking her biggest feature on a bonus disc with some of her lesser hits as part of a deluxe with maybe a dvd of her videos.

I think the track listing is good, however I think it should include a couple new songs and a deluxe edition featuring collaborations and S&M Remix.

I don't think every Single she has ever released should be included as she doesn't need the likes of You Da One and Te Amio etc.

If I was going to have a pure Greatest Hits with only her actual greatest hits on I would only have:

Pon de Replay,
SOS,
Unfaithful,
Umbrella,
Don't Stop The Music,
Take A Bow,
Disturbia,
Russian Roulette,
Rude Boy,
Only Girl (In The World),
What's My Name,
S&M,
We Found Love,
Where Have You Been.
Bonus: Love The Way You Lie.

I reckon Rihanna should follow suit perhaps of The Immaculate Collection!

Have every single enhanced and remixed! BUT call it Rihanna: Singles From The Urban Island or something original rather than "The Hits" or something....as some singles arent necessarily "hits" but massive single releases and duets etc.

Especially Take Care and Princess Of China!!! all need to be there...plus perhaps of coruse new material....ow can she not??? three songs....a R&B ballad style, an experimental sound and a Dance one...brill!

Ooh ill do my own list. I don't count features as apart of an artist's greatest hits, especially as most of Rihanna's collabs are only her singing the chorus several different times

Mine would be

Barbados Princess: The Singles Collection
Disc 1

1) Pon De Replay
2) If It's loving that you want
3) SOS
4) Unfaithful
5) We Ride
6) Umbrella
7) Shut up and Drive
8) Hate that I love you
9) Don't stop the music
10) Take a bow
11) If I ever see your face again
12) Disturbia
13) Rehab

Barbados Queen: The Singles Collection
Disc 2

1) Russian Roulette
2) Rude Boy
3) Te Amo
4) Hard
5) Rockstar 101
6) Only girl
7) What's my name
8) S&M
9) California king bed
10) Cheers
11) We found love
12) You da one
13) Where have you been
14) Next single from Talk era
15) New song - an upbeat
15) New song - a ballad

For me, a GH would never be that great for Rihanna because i find her best songs are either the songs that charted low or were never released at all but it depends how you rank yourself as a fan. I suppose I am a die hard fan

I like but it needs to be a bit more concise i think if i had to rework it would go as follows:

Pon De Replay
SOS
Unfaithful
Umbrella
Don't stop the music
Take a bow
disturbia
Russian roulette
rude boy
only girl
whats my name s&m
we found love
where have you been
talk that tak
new
new

and a bonus deluxe with lesser hits and her biggest features

If its loving that you want
we ride
Shut up and drive
rehab
hard
te amo
california king bed
cheers (drink to that)
Man Down
you da one
Live Your Life
Run This Town
Love The Way You Lie
Who's That Chick
Take Care

I'd have (in no particular order right now):

SOS
Pon de Replay
We Ride
Hate That I Love You
Umbrella
Shut Up And Drive
Don't Stop The Music
If I Never See Your Face Again
Disturbia
Rehab
Te Amo
Russian Roulette
Rude Boy
What's My Name
Love The Way You Lie
Only Girl (In The World)
S&M
We Found Love
Where Have You Been
2 or 3 new songs

I would call it a Singles Collection rather than a Greatest Hits.

Rihanna greatest hits? So We Found Love & Umbrella on repeat then?

Wow, round of applause followed by a standing ovation for this funny person