So I like making CDs for me to listen in my car and I'm making a Kylie one. I want to include a live version of "Your Disco Needs You" and I'm between her Showgirl version and her X version (links of both of them below).

Non Kylie fans are welcome to watch and share their opinion.

I'm leaning towards X because it sounds less nasal but there's something about the Showgirl one...



Showgirl: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LkxnSNqYIAg&ob=av2e

X: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JJipQdMJNL4

keep in mind that performance (dancing, costumes etc..) doesn't count since this is for my car.

From memory Although I prefer x version, I think showgirl is better for the car if that doesn't sound mental, but then you could have both really As long as there spaced out !

The thing is I already have the album version of the song so I don't want to have the same song three times.

Why do you think that the Showgirl version is better for the car?

Just don't have it up too loud or people are gonna know...

X. Me and my mum used to always play it in the car...

Shall we take it to the opera?!

Ooooooooooooooo-ooooooooooooooooooooooooooo-ooooooooooooooooooooo-oooooooooooooooooooooooooo.....

hahahaha. That part's awesome. I think I'll go with X.

Showgirl is a better performance visually (more complicated routine, different outfits, better staging) although X is great too. Vocally though X is significantly better I think, so I'll go with that.

I think her voice in general improved from X and onwards.

This one is good. There's a problem with the music so she sings it acapella.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g3WHwS3zuDA

Yea I know, I've seen that one but I don't think it's good car music. The audience is too loud and the sound is not good. It's a great clip though.