Originally Posted by homer2012:
“Please check out pink, Beyonce, Gaga, Justin Timberlake etc amazing they dance even singinging while 50ft in the air upside down and still sound LIVE and better than Tweedy.
Tweedy has to pre record her vocals and have autotune adjust the rest.
again when a singer is announced to "be performing Live" normally means there miming and Tweedy did just that on the voice, Tweedy doesn't have a strong voice to carry off singing live.
She mimed on the xfactor and even had her performance taped before the "live" show as she couldn't take been caught out miming on live tv.”
gaga's my #1 fave artist so I know what an amazing performance is like.
Not everyone is the same though, for instance I like cheryl because I believe she has a sweet tone to her voice that is something the artists you've listed don't offer (even though I LOVE all of them)
Cheryl didn't mime on the voice in my opinion and im not gonna try and change your opinion but even if cheryl doesnt have a strong voice and a limited range there is something about her that is clearly getting her fans. Whether it be the voice, her looks, her dancing or her personality, it is all part of the package in being a pop star, and cheryl does that successfully.
You have to remember her roots at Popstars. I liked her voice then, and I like it now and so did the public. She doesn't always sing live and I can see why people would hate that as essentially she is a musician, I sorta agree that singers should NEVER mime no matter the circumstance. However when she does mime I respect that she plays to her strengths and always goes flat out in dancing and puts on a wicked performance than just being lazy (sometimes Britney).
Am I going to hate her for miming? No I get to see her for free on the TV, she can do what she wants, as long as she entertains me, shes done her job. If I paid to see her at concert thats a different story, but thankfully she never mimed during any Girls Aloud tours or when she was supporting Black Eyes Peas, so thats cool
Sorry for the essay